Svoboda | Graniru | BBC Russia | Golosameriki | Facebook

Should we dump our poor friend?

Kate de Brito

Friday, February 18, 2011 at 08:17am
 

Dear Bossy: The problem is with my friend...I have two really close girlfriends, we have been friends since high school, always really close.

One of my friends, I’ll call her Ann, is like me - likes to go out and have fun, has a good job with a good salary. The other friend, lets call her Betty, has always been a little shy and a homebody, but has a good heart and is a sweet girl. Buuuut...Betty has made some life choices that are a bit different to Ann and me. She chose to have a baby and stop working young (age 19) and has married and pretty much became a house wife. Money is always tight as her husband doesn’t make much money, and obviously, with a child, she can’t come out very often. However, Ann and I have always accomodated this - making dinner dates at cheaper restaurants for when Betty has money, doing child-friendly activities so she can bring her five-year-old son, catch up at home for coffee and cheap nights in with drinks and DVDs at someone’s house.

But, of late, Ann and I are getting a bit tired of the same old thing all the time, so we’ve been going out without Betty - concerts, more expensive dinners, shopping trips - things that Betty doesn’t have money for. We don’t want to rub it in her nose that we can afford to do things that she can’t, so we always invite her really casually, or don’t mention these more expensive get togethers, while still making time to do things with her that don’t cost much. On a couple of occasions when we’ve wanted to do something that costs a bit more, Ann and I have paid for Betty to come with us, but we don’t want to make a habit out of this as we might have money to have fun, but we aren’t millionaires!!

However, recently Betty found out about one outing - a night out at a club- we had invited her but not really mentioned much more as she said she was too broke/couldn’t get a babysitter. Ann and I had a great night—and in the next few days heard from mutual friends that Betty had been bad-mouthing us, saying we had abandoned her and left her out of things. She had been invited but said she wouldn’t be able to come—what else are we supposed to do?! We’ve since invited her out for coffee, and to take walks, (things we would all usually do together) and she has avoided us making weak excuses.

Ann and I are getting tired of having to act like we are broke when we work hard to earn money!! But at the same time, Betty has been a good friend and is a sweet person, and we don’t want to lose her as a friend.  Betty made the choices that have led to her current situation, so Ann and I don’t want to have to pay for everything just because we made different choices.

What is the best way to move on from here? Can we be friends even if we make more money, or is it time to let this friendship go??

Bossy says: Yes, let the friendship go. Go out and enjoy your concerts and expensive dinners and shopping trips. These will sustain you all through your life. Friendship, on the other hand - especially to someone poor - is probably just a waste of time. You will gain far more solace in your darkest hours from a new dress than you ever would from dear, sweet Betty.

Of course I’m not serious OP, and nor should you be when you ask do we let this friendship go? You have acted so far in a way that shows you can be a considerate and caring friend. Don’t stop now.

Clearly you are a young woman who wants to enjoy the fruits of her labour. The problem with enjoying your fruits is it can make you forget things that are really important. I’m impressed you have tried so hard to include Betty in the past. And it must be annoying that she doesn’t appreciate the lengths you have gone to include her.

But Betty is feeling left out and you would in her position too - whether your life situation was a result of your “choices” or not.

Betty is probably more than happy she is at home with her lovely children to care for. Part of the time. And part of the time she is probably frustrated and resentful she cannot live the sort of life you live.

Yes, this is her issue. No, it is not fair for her to blame you. And yes, she needs to understand you have your own lives.

But you need to extend your empathy too. Invite her for lunch - insist she comes - and talk to her openly about how you feel. Tell her how much you care about her. Tell her you have heard she feels left out. Explain it’s not your intention and you would like her to be part of everything. But acknowledge there are many times she is unable to afford these sorts of activities.

If you want to badly enough you will make this work. And you should. Because in many years from now when you face real life issues - like death of family member, job loss, divorce or your husband rooting his secretary - you will want good friend around you. They are what counts in the end.

Have Your Say

Show Oldest | Newest first    Page 1 of 3      1 2 3 >

come on get a load of yourself. she is a friend. friends dont dis on friends coz they aint got no more. get a grip on it. whats wrong with cheap dinners and stuff? shes has a kid FFS youre probably only wanting to go to the clubs to get smashed and get taken home by some tossa who prey on drunk sluts. i bet youre fat too.

leave her alone she doesnt deserve you.

ps go have a long lunch at some innerwest cafe you pooris.

Chi replied to Badly Packed Kebab
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:16am)

Exactly this, and if the OP decides to have a child and finds herself lost (as many first-time parents do) you can be damn sure that her friendship with Betty will be worth more than fancy restaurants!

Danno replied to Badly Packed Kebab
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:39am)

Predictable as always Captain douche bag

Sahara replied to Badly Packed Kebab
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:50am)

I often give talks at seminars about building a successful career.

I always make sure I say something really controversial because it attracts press and starts people taking about you. It the old saying that any publicity is good publicity.

One thing I tell people during these seminars is that one of the biggest barriers to becoming a success is having poor friends and they should dump any friend with an income of less than $100,000 p.a.

The gasps of shock/horror from the audience never fail to occur and it’s all I can do to hold a straight face.

However, the highly exaggerated point is that high achievers don’t want to do the things that poor people do. If you “wanted to have cheap dinners and stuff” then why send your life working your tail off to become successful?

There is much more to life than material things. It is commendable that you consider your friend but doing things behind her back is not really nice. You should still invite her regardless of whether or not you feel she has the money. Its her choice, if she can’t afford it, she should tell you so, not you making an assumption.

It’s no wonder she is bagging you out, she feels betrayed and by all means, has every right to. I suggest you meet up and tell her why you did it, why you felt you had to sneak around. Apologize to her and let her know that you were not going out of way to be spiteful. Tell her you were just being considerate and by all means next time let her know you’ll ask her no matter what.

Im sure she already knows that you make an effort to accommodate her needs, but sneaky around like 5 year kids is only going to alienate and chastise her.

Sokrates of Sydney (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (08:26am)
Bec - the OP replied to Sokrates
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:05pm)

But we do invite her, I said that in my original email. You’ve totally missed my point, and that is that even when we invite her and accomodate her, it’s never enough. It’s pretty shit advice to say just keep doing what we are already doing if the result is the same. We have been open with her!!

Loving it replied to Sokrates
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:37pm)

I am not sure I agree with all of this. I do not invite all of my friends to everything I do. I invite people based on whether it is something they would enjoy and if I think they would want to come. I definitely have friends I would not ask to something because I know it would be financially out of their reach and it is embarassing for them to have to explain that to me. Friends with little ones I might ask to different things than the single girls, friends who have stacks of cash I might ask to different things than those who are watching their pennies. There is no malice or exclusion. If I invite one friend and not another it is not because I am sneaking around.

I agree that you need to talk to her about the issue and explain that you were acting in good faith and being considerate. But at the same time I do not think you should feel obligated to invite every friend you have to everything you do.

You should definitely let Betty go, OP.

Since wealth is important, I’m sure you’ll be happy to know that she’d be far richer without you.

just a suggestion replied to Mahhrat
Fri 18 Feb 11 (10:55am)

hey everybody -

She had been invited but said she wouldn’t be able to come—what else are we supposed to do?! We’ve since invited her out for coffee, and to take walks, (things we would all usually do together) and she has avoided us making weak excuses.

she’s already avoiding the OP so problem solved! Bit of a non-issue.

OP, you’ve been dumped. Perfectly understandable on Betty’s part.

Tim replied to Mahhrat
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:32pm)

C’Mon Mahrat,
how is it OP’s fault that Betty is a povo?
OP makes time to spend with Betty but sometimes wants to be able to go places that Betty won’t be able to afford.
If Betty was a true friend she wouldn’t care that OP goes to spend her money at these places and would enjoy the times that they actually have together.
Instead Betty was bad mouthing OP behind her back for “abandoning” her. What a joke.
Betty is jealous that she is pov and OP isn’t, but doesn’t want to make the necessary life choices to change it.
Too Bad.

Badly Packed Kebab replied to Mahhrat
Fri 18 Feb 11 (01:01pm)

you are such a wally

Are you considering ditching her friendship because she’s got less money than you, or because you have heard from others that she’s badmouthed you?

Do you trust those acquaintences who told you she said this stuff more than Betty, who you say is a sweet, lovely lady?

Either way, I think it suggests you aren’t the nicest friend to have. I’d be mortified if my so called friend toyed with ending their friendnship with me either because of rumour or because I was less financially endowed than they are.

BTW, have you considered that Betty’s life choices make her a strong, resilient, patient, practical and warm person?  Just because she hasn’t the time or money to party hard, it doesn’t make her life choices poor ones. Not that you say that - but your letter does have the tone of the type who just can’t fathom marriage and motherhood just yet. I suspect Betty has grown up quicker than you have.

Blossy of Canberra (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (08:42am)
Sittin' Pretty replied to Blossy
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:01am)

Are you kidding me?!?!
You think that just because she has a child she is more mature? By your logic people without children are what exactly? Pathologically childish themselves? And every person who has a child at 19 and has never had a job other than motherhood are the people who made the best decisions in their lives? Are the ones who have “grown up quicker” than the rest of us?
Forgive me for being of the opinion that says that is beyond condescending. I have friends whom I love that had children very young. When I am with them we play with their kids and we talk about things that they are interested in. And that’s great fun. But at the same time they do not get angry at me when I don’t invite them out for activities that they can not afford.  ‘Betty’ needs to own the choices she made and accept the consequences of them.
Not one of my friends with children make me feel bad about not having children myself. That is not something I have ever wanted for my life and they can understand that. And on the other side of that I can appreciate and admire how hard they work for their families. Women who go around thinking that they are so enlightened and superior to others simply because they have procreated need a serious reality check. I don’t think there is anything wrong with having children, so what gives you the right to think there is something wrong with not?

Sittin' Pretty replied to Blossy
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:09am)

And also - this is not the middle ages. Being ready to “fathom marriage and motherhood” does not make you more mature; or for that matter strong, resilient, patient, practical and warm. It just means that you have different priorities.
The first half of your post is quite perceptive and intelligent, but the last paragraph is just ignorant.

Paul replied to Blossy
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:22am)

Good Point!

Bec - the OP replied to Blossy
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:08pm)

It was from a trusted friend, he would have nothing to gain by telling us that she bitched about us.

And the problem is not that she is poor —I grew up poor, and had to fight very hard to get to where I am in my life, so I don’t hold that against her. I just don’t think it’s fair that she should start to resent me because now I can afford to do things that cost money. Why is the onus on me to change my habits, and not on her to be more accepting. I’ve always been accepting of her choices!!

Ditch the friend, she’s better off with out you.

Look forward to when you pop one out and begin to understand what your “Friend” has gone through to bring a child into the world.

Oh and you know I have some great old friends, we don’t need to spend heaps of money enriching those bonds, we go and have a couple of coffees on a sat or sunday and enjoy intelligent, stimulating discussions on the state of the world today. No one spends more then 10 bucks and we usually have a 2 or 3 hour session. We’ve pretty much been to every coffee place in town. There are lots of cheap alternatives where you can still have fun.

So wake up ya stoopid turkey!

Sincerely,

Dr. Opkick of Planet Zero (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (08:43am)
Bec - the OP replied to Dr. Opkick
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:13pm)

Oh, wow, geez - I never thought of going out for coffee. You have saved the day!! Good for you, buddy.

And if you can’t read the sarcasm in that you need a lesson in understanding written tone.

But how many times can we go out for coffee? We do go for coffee a lot. But does that mean we should be limited to coffee? There are a lot of other things to do as well, and yes, some of them cost a bit more money, should we all miss out because one person will be resentful of the rest?

I can understand your frustration.  In your letter it sounds like you’ve done a lot for her, which is great and what friends are really about.  I also totally agree that you don’t want to go paying for her to do things with you.

Sounds like she may be feeling very insecure about you guys going out without her that the only friends that hung around after the baby was born are leaving her.  Maybe you need to sit with her and explain to her why you don’t invite her.  Because she doesn’t have the money and you can’t afford to cover you all the time.  Let her make the decision about what you do from there (invite her or not)

But I have to say one thing...you get bored of hanging out with your friends?  I rarely go clubbing because that BORES me to tears!!!!  So much rather have a nice dinner, bottle of wine and DVD with my friends than clubbing.

Kat (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (08:49am)
Smidgeling replied to Kat
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:36am)

Thank you for being one of the only people not to badmouth the OP.

It’s pretty obvious that she doesn’t want to ditch someone over money, but she doesn’t want to be chastised for having money and going out.

I think if the friend was grown up and took some responsibilit for her choices initially, instead of badmouthing the OP, there wouldn’t be a problem to begin with.

Bec - the OP replied to Kat
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:16pm)

Thanks for your understanding, and your good advice. I think you’re right about the conversation needing to be had, even if it is a little awkward.

Just as a side note, it’s not always clubbing, that was just an example. Sometimes just going to the movies is financially out of reach for ‘Betty’, so we are having to make constant concessions for her. It just gets a little tiring. Sometimes you just want to do something (like going out) without feeling judged, or feeling like you are being a bitch to your friends, especially when you have tried hard to accomodate their needs a lot of the time.

OP poor people are the bane of everyone’s existence they should be shipped off to an island where they can all be poor together!  They’re not human so shouldn’t be treated like one.

JuiceBunny of Sydney (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (08:51am)
Mahhrat replied to JuiceBunny
Fri 18 Feb 11 (11:06am)

Yes, but we all know what happened to the Golgafrinchams…

Ther thing you have to learn is that after high school, you start new jobs, new lovers, make new friends, move to new cities, get married, get divorced, have kids. Very few friendships from high school last, weill not in the same form they were when you were BFFs.

AFR (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (08:52am)
Bec - the OP replied to AFR
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:20pm)

Well obviously. Most of the friends I went to high school with I no longer have contact with. Same with old colleagues, old boyfriends etc. People move on, grow up, life changes. But that’s why the few really long-term friendships are the hardest to break, and why I’m quite sad about this current situation.

You’re friend is jealous because she chose to the path to boredom, dullness and baby breeding.

As someone who’s chosen not to have children because life is too short to be tied down with screaming kids, most of my ‘friends’ who have gone down this path to tedium have passed by the way side because our lives are so different.  I’m not prepared to spend time listening to boring stories about their kids, and they are not interested in my life.  And that’s fine.

But don’t worry, the people who care about you for who you are won’t bitch about you behind your back.

Betty needs to understand that you are allowed to go out without her. Her own choices affect her own lifestyle and this is not your problem.

You need to tell her when you are going out and ensure you include her in the conversation so she doesn’t feel left out. That doesn’t mean she needs to come with you but if you tell her then this is her choice and if she gets snippy about it say that you understand but she also has things that you don’t have (a kid etc). It is not your job to apologise for your actions though.

In the end it is very difficult for singles and those with young kids to keep the same kind of friendship as you live in very different worlds. People change and their frendships evolve with them.

Semiotic (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:04am)
Loving it replied to Semiotic
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:43pm)

I actually want to comment on Life’s Too Short to Drink Bad Wine’s comment above but for some reason the comment button is broken. LTSDBW do your really categorise people into ‘breeders and therefore boring’ and ‘non breeders who are therefore interesting’? seems a little simplistic to me. My friendship group is made up of both parents and non parents. Having children in their lives does not make them more or less interesting.

Should you dump broke Betty?

Yes. Broke Betty will be better off without a rich beyatch like you as a so-called “friend”.

Good luck to Broke Betty!

Agent 86 of Brisbane (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:07am)

What is the best way to move on from here? Can we be friends even if we make more money, or is it time to let this friendship go??
Seriously move on! You’ll be doing your ‘poor’ friend a massive favour.
Oh and get your head out of your ass!

nicb (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:08am)

‘your husband rooting his secretary’ lulz

JesseJamesJr of Harbour (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:08am)

it sounds like you’ve made a lot of effort to keep this friendship going so don’t stop now.

We all make different choices in life. some people in their late 20s or 30s are still going out and enjoying life while friends around them are settling down into marriage and kids. This is not a reason to assume because they made a different choice that suddenly they can’t be the same friend. The friendship does change, thats for certain. and you’ve already seen this with your friend having a child and needing to accommodate her lack of finances. but don’t give up on the friendship!

She has still remained a good friend to you and will continue to be if you continue to try and make an effort.  always invite your friend, dont think you need to pay for her to come but at least acknowledge her limitations in doing some activities - even if its giving her plenty of notice to save up for a concert or a good night out at the club.

questionable (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:08am)

And down the track when you and Ann potentially look to settle down and have children Betty would be there supporting you even though she’s been through it all already.

Circumstances change and the shoe could quite easily be on the other foot.  What if you or Ann lost your jobs tomorrow, what would you have to show for yourselves?

I like Bossy’s idea of having a chat with her, if you’re all as good friends as you say then that shouldn’t be too hard to achieve.

shari (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:24am)

Today it is obvious that people do not know what being a true friend really is. It is in being with them. It has nothing to do with money. For example Facebook has cheapened the definition of what a “FRIEND” really is. So for many friends is all about having a good time out with them spending money or tweeting them. A real friendship is being close together sharing life’s experiences in confidential private words.

Acushla (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:24am)
Bec - the OP replied to Acushla
Fri 18 Feb 11 (12:24pm)

Wow, sancitmonious much? Get off your high horse, Pops.

My friends and I have been close long before anyone even knew what Facebook was. And we have shared life events; births, marriages, break ups, family tragedies, good times.

The sad thing is when people’s feelings, both mine and my friends, start to cloud things, and make it a little bit hard to be around each other.

Kudos to you for trying to include Betty, but yes, you have to understand that she would probably LOVE to go out with you and Ann more than she does.

I like Bossy’s suggestions, and I think she’s right.

And friends are really important. Good/close friends are the family you choose to have, and when you’re going through a hard time they’re an important rock to have at your side. Don’t discard them lightly.

Miss A of Melbourne (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:29am)

Ok so you have these great jobs and you earn heaps of money, well good for you that doesnt mean you leave your friends out.

I have two close friends lets call them Fifi and Blaise, we each earn decent amounts of money, we all like to party, we all get paid in different ways. So if we want to go out but one of us has no money, we all chip in and it is reciprocated next time.

I know its hard, because she doesnt earn as much as you and she doesnt have that giant pole stuck up her arse like you, but hey shes supposed to be a friend and a good one at that. You dont just let that go like a useless secretary.

Stacebags! (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:30am)

Yay Bossy!!! So true!! Life has a way of dealing out some horrible cards as well as good ones and having a true friend like Betty around makes your life worthwhile. I’m telling you now out of experience, if you find a good true honest friend you’ll never regrett having them in your lives. It is so hard to make these kind of friendships. They come with being friends for years and trusting and taking care of one another. And sounds like you have done this with Betty. I’m telling you she will be there for you one day when you really need her. She might not have money at the monent but she has kindness, warmth, the time to listen to you and she values your friendship. These friends are everything in life. Wish I had more of them. But the ones I do have, I may be in a different state now, but I still keep in regular contact by email and ph. Don’t let them go. I actually had a couple more of these close friends, but due to marriage, children, moving, life taking different paths, have lost contact over the years. Have tried hard to find them via fb and ringing her last current surname though have had no success. I think one has married and moved so have no idea what surname to look for or even what city. Will probarbly never see her again now apart from a remote chance occurance. These are big regretts. Nothing can replace close true friends. And very difficult to make new ones as you get older or move. Alot of people have their tight niches and aren’t wanting to expand on their friends. Which is understandable. Take care of your friends as they are the ones who will help and support you through the difficult times in life we are all bound to have. They are also the ones who will be happy for you and will make your day in the best times of your life. Bossy’s advice is great, I would go with this, explain the situation to Betty, still invite her out ( even though she may not be able to attend) at least you have given her the opportunity.  Still arrange the less expensive options as well that she can afford, so you all have time to catch up. This friendship is definately one worth having , so take care of it.

Rooney (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:33am)

Grrrr.... what Bossy said.

Friendship or money, OP?  You decide.

Elphaba (Reply)
Fri 18 Feb 11 (09:33am)

Show Oldest | Newest first    Page 1 of 3      1 2 3 >

Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide a name, you may use a screen name – this will be published with your comment, and a working email address – not for publication, but for verification. The suburb/location field is optional.
( Read our publication guidelines ).


Submit your comments here:

   
 

How to add a link: Enter the text you wish to be clickable, select it and click the 'Link' button to enter the link details in the popup box. Maximum of 2 links.


* Required Fields

 

Insert an emoticon Insert an emoticon



 

Profile

Kate de Brito

Kate de Brito

Got a question? Ask Bossy. No-holds-barred advice from modern-day agony aunt Kate de Brito. It's the advice your friends and relatives are probably too polite to give.


By emailing a question to Ask Bossy you accept your question may appear on the Ask Bossy blog on news.com and in The Daily Telegraph. Questions cannot be answered privately. Once a question is posted we reserve the right not to remove it.

Advertisement

View Entries by Date

February 2011
S M T W T F S
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28          

Subscribe

RSS Feed of all the latest Ask Bossy articles ATOM Feed of all the latest Ask Bossy articles
Subscribe to receive the latest from Ask Bossy

Email a friend

To email this article to a friend, fill in the form below

Message:

close  x

From around the News Blog Network