Svoboda | Graniru | BBC Russia | Golosameriki | Facebook
May 12, 2011 | Log In | Sign Up

Michael Shaw

Michael Shaw

GET UPDATES FROM Michael Shaw

Reading the Pictures: Framing Osama (and Obama)

Posted: 05/ 9/11 09:02 AM ET

Bin Laden rehearsing DoD

Now that the perceptual war surrounding the bin Laden operation has fully transitioned to the post-raid stage, I wanted to look at the first of two images the DoD has strategically used to undermine "the evil one." This screenshot, which I imagine most of you have already seen, is an outtake extracted from the trove of video captured in Abbottabad showcasing bin Laden rehearsing, and apparently flubbing a line.

If the point here is that bin Laden was overly scripted -- as well as overly concerned with his image, given the fact his beard is jet black while in other time-related pics and vids it is grey -- I give the DoD and the White House about a D- for the effort. Not only does the DoD know too well today's wars are fought as much on TV by celebrity brands (basic basic production techniques being standard-operating-procedure), so does the public.

Obama photo Staged bin Laden Announcement

That being the case -- and given the fact Obama re-staged the walk-out and first 30 seconds of his announcement of bin Laden's death for still cameras after he finished the live announcement on TV, this particular rip on bin Laden is a FAIL. (It's also a little funny, by the way, that the DoD would be ripping bin Laden for being a TV star after the GOP spent months attacking the charismatic, but then fresh-faced candidate Obama back in '08 as "The Celebrity," even likening him to Britney Spears and Paris Hilton).

Let me just be clear. I'm not ripping the DoD for propaganda, I get that is a major part of their business. What I'm ripping them for is weak propaganda, each failed effort having the result of undermining the effective stuff.

----------

For the latest in visual politics, visit BagNewsNotes (and follow us on Twitter).

----------
(photo 1: U.S. Department of Defense via  Denver Post caption: Osama bin Laden speaks in an undated image taken from videos seized by Navy SEALs in last weekend's raid and released Saturday. photo2 : Jason Reed/Reuters)

 

Follow Michael Shaw on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bagnewsnotes

Now that the perceptual war surrounding the bin Laden operation has fully transitioned to the post-raid stage, I wanted to look at the first of two images the DoD has strategically used to undermine...
Now that the perceptual war surrounding the bin Laden operation has fully transitioned to the post-raid stage, I wanted to look at the first of two images the DoD has strategically used to undermine...
 
Desde a morte de Osama bin Laden, também cresce o medo de retaliação por parte dos radicais. Até avó de Obama, q...
Obama Renews Endorsement for DREAM Act
Michelle Obama buzz building at Spelman College
Champion UConn to visit Obama, White House
RT : Bin Laden wanted to carry out attacks to prevent Obama from being reelected
Perry Snubs Obama, Wants More Than a Handshake [Politics]
Laid-off Government Worker To President Obama: "What Would You Do, If You Were Me?" -
DFW: Huckabee: Obama Not Invincible
RT : Obama administration invites Libyan opposition to White House
Hartley's Widow Slams Obama Admin. For Lack Of Action - Denver News Story - KMGH Denver
3 hours ago from web
Hey President Obama, You know what would get businesses to hire? GET RID OF OBAMACARE.
Obama presses Congress on cybersecurity measures
Obama no posará más para fotos de prensa, dice la Casa Blanca
3 hours ago from web
Mike Huckabee: Bin Laden Doesn't Make Obama Invincible
AP: Huckabee: Bin Laden doesn't make Obama invincible.
Watch: Obama speaks at Hispanic Prayer Breakfast
4 hours ago from web
Obama administration invites Libyan opposition to White House
Good move/ Obama administration considers moves to limit anonymous donations /
RT : Romney's speech making me more skeptical of his prospects in a GOP nomination, his rhetoric on "free riders" mirrors Obama
KSAT.com: Obama: Can't Have Amnesia On Immigration - President Obama says today's immigrants are no different than t...
 
  • Comments
  • 3
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
18 minutes ago (7:11 PM)
The author seems to have a little too much time on his hands analyzing this. First off, in regards to restaging the walkout, the writer-pho­tographer of the Reuters article made this statement:

"Every nationally­-televised Presidenti­al statement of historical significan­ce and of this nature, going back decades, is made specifical­ly for television­. The concept of accommodat­ing still photograph­ers immediatel­y after these events is a courtesy extended to us by EACH administra­tion so that a still record of the event is made by the independen­t press that work at the White House. To reproduce the same angle that viewers had just seen on TV, the still photograph­er must step right in front of the teleprompt­er and block the TV camera. This is the only way to do it, so stills cannot be in that position during the event. In addition, the noise made by the still cameras and the movement by the photograph­ers themselves would be an unnecessar­y distractio­n for the President if pictures were take during the live address. Our photo captions explain full disclosure that the pictures are taken following the actual address to make clear the circumstan­ces under which the picture was taken."

Second, the OBL "propagand­a" piece, OBL put himself on display with those tapes. I could not care less if it shows OBL in an unflatteri­ng light. There was nothing flattering about him to begin with. So, by all means, OBL needs to be shown as-is -- a monster with a very large ego.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jenna T
you can get cream for that
4 hours ago (3:36 PM)
The whole narrative is phony.

No wonder we are all so cynical.
8 hours ago (11:04 AM)
What an odd analysis.