Prayers for Rain
4/5
()
About this ebook
When a former client jumps naked from a Boston landmark, Private Investigator Patrick Kenzie wants to know why. Once a perky young woman in love with life, her suicide is the final fall in a spiral of self-destruction.
What Kenzie discovers is a sadistic stalker who targeted the woman and methodically drove her to her death – a monster that the law can’t touch. But Kenzie can. He and his former partner, Angela Gennaro, will fight a mind-twisting battle against the psychopath, even as he turns tricks on them…
Prayers for Rain is another superior thriller from Dennis Lehane, the bestselling and acclaimed author of Mystic River, Shutter Island, and Gone, Baby, Gone.
Dennis Lehane
Dennis Lehane is the author of thirteen novels—including the New York Times bestsellers Live by Night; Moonlight Mile; Gone, Baby, Gone; Mystic River; Shutter Island; and The Given Day—as well as Coronado, a collection of short stories and a play. He grew up in Boston, MA and now lives in California with his family.
Read more from Dennis Lehane
Shutter Island Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5FaceOff Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Drop Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Friends of Eddie Coyle: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Red Eye: Patrick Kenzie vs. Harry Bosch: An Original Short Story Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Coronado: Stories Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Final Confession: The Unsolved Crimes of Phil Cresta Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5USA Noir: Best of the Akashic Noir Series Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to Prayers for Rain
Titles in the series (6)
Darkness, Take My Hand Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Drink Before the War Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Gone, Baby, Gone: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sacred: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Prayers for Rain Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Moonlight Mile: A Kenzie and Gennaro Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related ebooks
Sacred: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Moonlight Mile: A Kenzie and Gennaro Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Darkness, Take My Hand Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Drink Before the War Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Gone, Baby, Gone: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Coronado: Stories Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Galveston: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Savages: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Gentlemen's Hour: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5She Rides Shotgun: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Broken Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Sins of the Fathers Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Kings of Cool: A Prequel to Savages Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dead I Well May Be: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The King of Lies: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Lady in the Lake: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Dirty South: A Thriller Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Down River: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Kill Me Twice: A compulsively gripping thriller perfect for fans of Harlan Coben Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsRed Eye: Patrick Kenzie vs. Harry Bosch: An Original Short Story Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Informant Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Blue Edge of Midnight Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Jealous Kind: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Hanging: A Thriller Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Force: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Girl in the Green Raincoat: A Tess Monaghan Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Feral Detective: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Two Minute Rule Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Styx Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Hard-boiled Mystery For You
Michael Connelly's Harry Bosch Series Reading Order Updated 2019: Compiled by Albie Berk Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Don’t Know Jack: The Hunt for Jack Reacher, #1 Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Devil's Necktie Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Friends of Eddie Coyle: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Colorado Kid Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5To Live and Die in L.A. Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Fourth Monkey Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Yiddish Policemen's Union: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Hunter: And Other Stories Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Neon Rain: A Dave Robicheaux Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5New Orleans Noir: The Classics Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Sins of the Fathers Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Librarian: The unforgettable, completely addictive psychological thriller from bestseller Valerie Keogh Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5High Priest of California Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Hard Fall: A Gripping Mystery Thriller: Thomas Blume, #1 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5By Way of Sorrow Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Borrowed Time Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Killer in the Wind Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Six Easy Pieces: Easy Rawlins Stories Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dog on It: A Chet and Bernie Mystery Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Still Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Working Stiff Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Promised Land Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Sword-Edged Blonde: An Eddie LaCrosse Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Binding Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dirty Money: A Parker Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Welcome to the Game Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5In the Midst of Death Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related categories
Reviews for Prayers for Rain
58 ratings23 reviews
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5More cartoonish than the last but I'll never tire of their banter.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5[Prayers For Rain] by Dennis LehaneKenzie & Gennaro Series Book #53.5 StarsFrom The Book:When a former client jumps naked from a Boston landmark, Private Investigator Patrick Kenzie wants to know why. Once a perky young woman in love with life, her suicide is the final fall in a spiral of self-destruction.What Kenzie discovers is a sadistic stalker who targeted the woman and methodically drove her to her death – a monster that the law can’t touch. But Kenzie can. He and his former partner, Angela Gennaro, will fight a mind-twisting battle against the psychopath, even as he turns tricks on them…My Views:I like Dennis Lehane's writing style. He even manages to insert some humor into stories about psychopaths and various other types of misfits. The main problem with this book was that his lead characters constantly did such unpredictable, unprofessional, unbelievable, and entirely unnecessary things to achieve their goal. It made the book about 120 pages too long. This small clitch won't deter me from reading more of this series, but hope he sticks more to his main story line in the future.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Good one excepting the bantering.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5This is my first Denis Lehane story and I am hooked. The suspense just keepsbuilding until you can't put it down.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I must confess... I am not a fan of the hard-boiled American "Private Eye", who relies more on his physical prowess than mental powers to catch criminals. Hercule Poirot and his little grey cells, and the cosy drawing-room British murder mystery where violence almost always takes place backstage, is more to my taste. Given my usual predilections, I might never have discovered Dennis Lehane, had Martin Scorsese not made a movie out of Shutter Island. I wanted to see the movie; and since I make it a point never to see a mystery movie without reading the book, I read the book-and was hooked.
Lehane writes beautifully (I mean, it is not great literature, but one does not look for it in a murder mystery); Prayers for Rain will hook you and pull you in from the first page, and the pace never lets up. The breathtaking pace is not built through incessant physical action, but rather through the steadily increasing tempo of dramatic tension. The book is so well structured that succeeding scenes almost naturally flow out of their predecessors. We never feel that somebody is building the narrative, rather it is flowing by itself. The novelist is almost invisible.
The characterisation is also superb. Even the secondary characters are well-delineated. Lehane takes pains to build the world of his story. And in the creation of Wesley Dawe, the author has succeeded in creating a truly evil villain, somebody who will really makes us shudder.
Are there flaws? Sure, for a purist. There are some loose ends which are not tied up cleanly. The "omnipotent" mailman as a literary device is straight out of G.K.Chesterton. Also, to make Wesley's and Scott's plans work, Lehane had to create a lot of co-conspirators, which makes the story rather far-fetched.
However, all these can be ignored. The sheer pace and energy of the narrative will carry you through, bug-eyed and dry-mouthed, till the last page is turned, when the final twist will blow you away. The novel thrills... and what more does a "thriller" require to do? - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Karen Nichols, a seemingly perfect prime and proper young lady, hires private detective Patrick Kenzie to warn off Cody Falk, a stalker who has a history of rape and abuse of women. Patrick and his new sidekick, Bubba, who has the face of a deranged two-year-old but with the physique of a “steel boxcar with limbs” pay Cody a visit. Bubba rearranges Cody’s car and they leave with suitable threats of potential carnage should anything happen to Karen. Six months later Karen jumps naked from a six story building and Patrick wants to learn what happened.
He learns that Karen’s boyfriend had been killed in a car accident and that she had been raped before her descent into drugs and despair. But he also discovers that someone had been setting her up.
Feeling somewhat contrite at one point, Patrick decides to attend Mass in spite of being more than a lapsed Catholic. He’s astonished by the priest’s short sermon. “Father McKendrick definitely had Red Sox tickets. The parishioners looked dazed, but happy. The only thing good Catholics love more than God is a short service. Keep your organ music, your choir, keep your incense and processionals. Give us a priest with one eye on the Bible and the other on the clock, and we’ll pack the place like it’s a turkey raffle the week before Thanksgiving.”
In a previous book in the series, Patrick had split up with his onagain-offagain sweetheart and investigative partner, Angie Gennaro. This case gets them back together. They need to discover why Karen had slowly descended into a quagmire of drugs and prostitution before committing suicide. They discover that her fiancé might have been deliberately killed in what had apparently purely an accident while crossing the street.. Karen's family is uncooperative and clearly hiding something. The family secrets begin to unravel.
Despite some of its rather fantastical aspects — how convenient that Angie's grandfather is a mob boss with the power to call off the mob fangs at one point, and the level of evil strains credulity — this book reminds me a lot of some of Ross MacDonald’s better work, a peeling off of layers of ostensible respectability to reveal putrid corruption and evil permeating family relationships. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The fifth, and apparently last, of Lehane's mysteries featuring Patrick Kenzie and Angela Gennaro. Angie broke away form Patrick, profesionally and personally, at the end of its predecessor, Gone, Baby, Gone, and Patrick begins this book hanging out with Bubba. Lehane doesn't make a big deal of it, but he does a nice job of showing Patrick having basically nowhere else to turn for camaraderie than to Bubba, the childhood friend whom we can almost read as representing Patrick's violent, messy side.Patrick helps Karen Nichols escape from a harasser, but fails to return a call from her months later, and learns subsequently that she has killed herself. Something tells him that her suicide was not a simple story and he begins to investigate it. Angie becomes involved (professionally), and they begin to realize that Karen was manipulated and driven to kill herself as part of a psychopath's crusade against her parents.In the course of tracking down the perpetrator, Angie and Patrick resume their personal relationship. Lehane does a nice job throughout the series with this aspect of things. Once again, questionable actions and extreme violence play a part in resolving the plot, and Patrick receives physical wounds to mirror the psychic wounds he takes from each case.I'm sorry to see this series come to an end.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I've always been a huge fan of Michael Connelly and when a friend recommended Dennis Lehane for me and said it was similar to Connelly I instantly picked up "Prayers for Rain".And what a superb book it was. Lehane writes some very good dialogue and some very intelligent and bare-bones descriptions of the action that is taking place.The first line in chapter 1 reads like this: "The first time I met Karen Nichols, she struck me as the kind of woman who ironed her socks."That is one hell of a opening line and you are instantly drawn into the world of private investigator Patrick Kenzin.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5PIs Patrick Kenzie and Angela Gennaro, with backup from friend Bubba Rugowski, investigate the harassment and suicide of Karen Nichols. Excellent, well-written story with good characterization and a plot full of twists and turns.
- Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5This is the second in Lehane’s Patrick Kenzie-Angela Gennaro series that I have read (after Gone, Baby, Gone), and I don’t think I cared for it much. I didn’t really like any of the characters, and the plot left me cold. I much prefer Lehane’s standalone books to his cynical, ultra-violent mystery series.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I found the characters in this book terrifying, between the mafia, the charismatic psychopath and the sociopathic mastermind.
- Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5in short it's a bit of an okay read - it is good to great in places however I found large chunks of it were a bit of a slog plus add to this there was a helluva lot of corn from the main, 2nd and 3rd characters. I Like the Author for his other great stand alone books, which is probably why I carried on reading this - had it been by somebody else an unknown to me then I would have binned it about a third of the way through.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5very good patrick kenzie is a private eye and he helps karon nichols and six months later she commits suicidehe finds that soeone drove her to do it
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Patrick Kenzie has lost some enthusiasm for his work since Angela Gennaro left their partnership.He's hired by Karen Nichols to stop a stalker from bothering her. Patrick and his pal, Bubba, scare off the attempted assailant. Then, thinking that the job is done, he goes about his business. When he recieives a call from Karen, a bit later, he doesn't think it's anything urgent and doesn't return the call.When he sees the news that Karen has committed suicide, Patrick is ashamed that he didn't care enough to call her back.He gets Angela to join him and recreates Karen's life, from the time he last saw her, to the time of her death.What he finds is a plot that someone created to destroy Karen's life and her will to live.Lehane tells an intriguing story about the depths to which a person can sink and how hopelessness can change a person's life. Variations of this theme have been told in the past, but Lehane does the job well and brings the reader into finding the reasons why and what outcome will happen.Patrick and Angela have a special manner between them. Their conversations together and with other characters are unique and make them people that the reader wants to know more about.This was a most enjoyable, stand alone, thriller.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Prayers for Rain has been in my TBR pile for quite a while--several years at least. Surely not since 1999, though my copy is a new, non-remaindered hardcover, so probably since 2000. I don't feel that bad about leaving it there, because there are still no new Kenzie/Gennaro stories, and it's a bit sad knowing I've read the last one in my TBR pile.The series is about PI Patrick Kenzie, his complex professional/romantic relationship with his partner Angie Gennaro, and their psychotic but extremely loyal pal Bubba Rogowski.This 5th book in the series starts with Kenzie & Gennaro split up, both personally and professionally, and Patrick's not taking it well, reevaluating his life as Angie had. A young woman comes to him for help with a simple stalker, and he solves the problem without breaking a sweat, or even seeing her again.Six months later, the same young woman, who'd been the epitome of "sweet girl next door", has committed suicide. The fact that she'd called him 3 months earlier and he'd forgotten to get back to her makes Patrick curious, so he starts to check things out. The more he learns, the more curious he becomes.Before long, he's enlisted Angie & Bubba's help, and they find themselves afoul of the local mob, and embroiled in a case that's looking more sinister by the minute.It's dark, with no easy answers, and Kenzie's brand of solution is always satisfying--violence when necessary, but always with a psychological angle, never pointless brute force. There's also humor in the darkness, like Bubba complaining when he doesn't get to just blow something up.What grabs me about this, and the other books in the series, are the complex characters. We get the motivations of everyone, not just the main characters, and they all ring true. And yes, I've really enjoyed the ups and downs of the Kenzie/Gennaro relationship. It's not a sweet, HEA one, but it sucked me in.I guess I'll have to break down now and get Lehane's non-series books. I'm assured they're just as good, though having seen the movie version of Mystic River, I'm a little wary of reading it.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The fifth, and presumably last, Kenzie and Gennaro story, Prayers for Rain was right up there with the rest of the series. Lehane is violent and doesn't sugar-coat his heroes. Instead, they make mistakes, do questionable things, and suffer the consequences - physical and psychological. As is usual, Lehane's plotting is crisp and the characters are fantastic. But what really shines is his writing. It's lyrical and horrific at the same time. Fair warning, though. He doesn't pull any punches when describing the violence Patrick and Angela experience.Recommended, but for best effect, start with the beginning of the series.
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Really good book. Very dark and very violent but the characters and the plot were excellent. Kenzie and Gennaro rock!
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5What started off as another excellent Lehane book was ruined by the last couple of pages for me, unfortunately. Still, up until then, it had been great. The mystery is convoluted, thought-provoking & keeps the suspense going strong. We get to see a lot more of & find out more about Bubba. That right there makes it worth reading. I got a little tired of Kenzie's flashes of brilliance. I would have preferred he just reason it out soundly.
Unfortunately, Lehane had to take the case an extra step. In itself, that wasn't too bad, kind of icing on the cake, but the idea that Kenzie would threaten - no promise - this devious man that he would come after him in the future was ridiculous. The guy was an unstable, one-time chess champion, who had proved he could & would resort to anything to destroy a person. The entire book was a fight through that very tangled web to get to the person ultimately responsible. So, we finally wind up with the true villain & Kenzie just walks? Very unsatisfactory.
I'll look forward to the next book, if only to see if the situation is retrieved. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nulla eget est faucibus, tristique sapien vel, ultrices risus. Phasellus laoreet sapien vel metus sodales consequat. Suspendisse potenti. Quisque sed lacinia ipsum. Aliquam porttitor aliquet risus in ullamcorper. Suspendisse potenti. Aliquam congue venenatis leo sit amet viverra. Pellentesque libero nisi, tincidunt vitae purus vel, dapibus luctus dui. Sed at scelerisque nunc, nec laoreet nisi. Ut non dui sit amet tortor efficitur pharetra. Aliquam porttitor a elit nec finibus. Mauris eleifend quam vitae vehicula vulputate. Maecenas in metus justo.
Aenean rutrum, ante eu faucibus ultricies, urna metus efficitur quam, et efficitur libero lectus et risus. Sed a tincidunt nunc. Proin rutrum turpis diam, sed porttitor turpis molestie eu. Donec convallis lacinia aliquam. Mauris luctus, ex nec suscipit mollis, lacus diam dapibus massa, ac dapibus mauris magna vitae justo. Morbi ultrices nulla augue, non rhoncus lorem auctor dictum. Nulla vitae mauris sit amet risus accumsan sodales. Aenean lectus turpis, imperdiet nec ipsum id, suscipit eleifend dui. Maecenas maximus luctus mauris. Donec auctor quis mi tincidunt gravida. Donec vitae auctor mauris. Nam tincidunt est sagittis, tristique sem vitae, tristique velit. Aliquam porttitor imperdiet convallis. Proin porttitor massa vitae nunc aliquam lacinia. Curabitur sed fermentum est. Quisque eu velit tincidunt, sollicitudin nunc a, hendrerit leo.
Nunc id arcu at arcu aliquam aliquam. Pellentesque habitant morbi tristique senectus et netus et malesuada fames ac turpis egestas. Quisque non tortor dignissim dui facilisis imperdiet. Nunc sapien mi, tincidunt a odio non, fringilla vehicula elit. Nam eget libero dui. Sed pretium volutpat porttitor. Ut ullamcorper ac justo id euismod. Mauris mattis semper orci, vitae commodo diam sagittis ac.
Nullam nunc nulla, convallis viverra eleifend ut, commodo sit amet sem. Vestibulum sagittis consequat quam, eleifend ullamcorper leo elementum eu. Nam luctus dolor sed faucibus posuere. Sed tortor nulla, molestie in lacinia et, luctus dictum sapien. Etiam ac tincidunt sem, vel vehicula nunc. Nullam quis metus vel quam ullamcorper consequat. Aliquam odio quam, auctor eu feugiat vel, egestas nec libero. Nulla ultricies mollis lobortis. Integer pulvinar leo non sapien auctor faucibus. Suspendisse potenti. Praesent cursus feugiat tortor et fringilla. Proin ultrices elit felis, in faucibus urna suscipit vitae. Curabitur auctor mauris at bibendum lobortis. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/55th in the Patrick Kenzie/Angela Gennaro series.Just when you think Lehane has reached a pinnacle, to your delight he outdoes himself. I didn’t think it was possible, but this book is, if anything better than its predecessor, Gone, Baby,Gone.A former client takes her life, and Kenzie can not understand why. Unwilling to let go and accept the official verdict of suicide, Kenzie begins investigating her life, trying to unravel the mystery of her rather sudden decline and self-destruction. He and Angie Gennaro have broken up both their professional partnership and their personal relationship as a consequence of the horrific case of child abduction they had worked together. But Angie rejoins Patrick to work out the puzzle. What they find is a deadly stalker.This is a flat-out thriller with some surprising and welcome developments of some of the recurring supporting characters in the series. The plot is the best yet. The writing continues to be the best in the field. Angie and Patrick continue to be real people with real lives outside of the work that they do together. You simply can not ask for more in any novel; the fact that the series not only holds up but continues to improve is some sort of miracle.A gripper, a real page turner, again this was a book I finished in one day because I simply could not put it down.Highly recommended.
1 person found this helpful
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sigh...no safety on a revolver people. Other than that, a pretty decent outing and what we thought would be the finale. Frankly, it should have been.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Good action and plot twists with characters I learned to care about. Would recommend this to anyone who enjoys the "Private Eye" mystery.
- Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5Not his best.
1 person found this helpful
Book preview
Prayers for Rain - Dennis Lehane
1
The first time I met Karen Nichols, she struck me as the kind of woman who ironed her socks.
She was blond and petite and stepped out of a kelly-green 1998 VW Bug as Bubba and I crossed the avenue toward St. Bartholomew’s Church with our morning coffee in hand. It was February, but winter had forgotten to show up that year. Except for one snowstorm and a few days in the subzeros, it had been damn near balmy. Today it was in the high forties, and it was only ten in the morning. Say all you want about global warming, but as long as it saves me from shoveling the walk, I’m for it.
Karen Nichols placed a hand over her eyebrows, even though the morning sun wasn’t all that strong, and smiled uncertainly at me.
Mr. Kenzie?
I gave her my eats-his-veggies-loves-his-mom smile and proffered my hand. Miss Nichols?
She laughed for some reason. Karen, yes, I’m early.
Her hand slid into mine and felt so smooth and uncallused it could have been gloved. Call me Patrick. That’s Mr. Rogowski.
Bubba grunted and slugged his coffee.
Karen Nichols’s hand dropped from mine and she jerked back slightly, as if afraid she’d have to extend her hand to Bubba. Afraid if she did, she might not get it back.
She wore a brown suede jacket that fell to midthigh over a charcoal cable-knit crewneck, crisp blue jeans, and bright white Reeboks. None of her apparel looked as if a wrinkle, stain, or wisp of dust had been within a country mile of it.
She placed delicate fingers on her smooth neck. A couple of real PIs. Wow.
Her soft blue eyes crinkled with her button nose and she laughed again.
I’m the PI,
I said. He’s just slumming.
Bubba grunted again and kicked me in the ass.
Down, boy,
I said. Heel.
Bubba sipped some coffee.
Karen Nichols looked as if she’d made a mistake coming here. I decided then not to lead her up to my belfry office. If people were uncertain about hiring me, taking them to the belfry usually wasn’t good PR.
School was out because it was Saturday, and the air was moist and without a chill, so Karen Nichols, Bubba, and I walked to a bench in the schoolyard. I sat down. Karen Nichols used an immaculate white handkerchief to dust the surface, then she sat down. Bubba frowned at the lack of space on the bench, frowned at me, then sat on the ground in front of us, crossed his legs, peered up expectantly.
Good doggie,
I said.
Bubba gave me a look that said I’d pay for that as soon as we were away from polite company.
Miss Nichols,
I said, how did you hear about me?
She tore her gaze away from Bubba and looked into my eyes for a moment in utter confusion. Her blond hair was cut as short as a small boy’s and reminded me of pictures I’ve seen of women in Berlin in the 1920s. It was sculpted tight against the skull with gel, and even though it wouldn’t be moving on its own unless she stepped into the wake of a jet engine, she’d clipped it over her left ear, just below the part, with a small black barrette that had a june bug painted on it.
Her wide blue eyes cleared and she made that short, nervous laugh again. My boyfriend.
And his name is…
I said, guessing Tad or Ty or Hunter.
David Wetterau.
So much for my psychic abilities.
I’m afraid I’ve never heard of him.
He met someone who used to work with you. A woman?
Bubba raised his head, glared at me. Bubba blamed me for Angie ending our partnership, for Angie moving out of the neighborhood, buying a Honda, dressing in Anne Klein suits, and generally not hanging out with us anymore.
Angela Gennaro?
I asked Karen Nichols.
She smiled. Yes. That’s her name.
Bubba grunted again. Pretty soon he’d start howling at the moon.
And why do you need a private detective, Miss Nichols?
Karen.
She turned on the bench toward me, tucked an imaginary strand of hair behind her ear.
Karen. Why do you need a detective?
A sad, crumpled smile bent her pursed lips and she looked down at her knees for a moment. There’s a guy at the gym I go to?
I nodded.
She swallowed. I guess she’d been hoping I’d figure it all out from that one sentence. I was certain she was about to tell me something unpleasant and even more certain that she had, at best, only a very passing acquaintance with things unpleasant.
He’s been hitting on me, following me to the parking lot. At first it was just, you know, annoying?
She raised her head, searched my eyes for understanding. Then it got uglier. He began calling me at home. I went out of my way to avoid him at the gym, but a couple of times I saw him parked out in front of the house. David finally got fed up and went to talk to him. He denied it all and then he threatened David.
She blinked, twisted the fingers of her left hand in the fist she’d made of her right. David’s not physically…formidable? Is that the right word?
I nodded.
So, Cody—that’s his name, Cody Falk—he laughed at David and called me the same night.
Cody. I hated him already on general principle.
He called and told me how much he knew I wanted it, how I’d probably never had a good, a good—
Fuck,
Bubba said.
She jerked a little, glanced at him, and then quickly back to me. Yeah. A good, well…in my life. And he knew I secretly wanted him to give me one. I left this note on his car. I know it was stupid, but I…well, I left it.
She reached into her purse, extracted a wrinkled piece of purple notepaper. In perfect Palmer script, she’d written:
Mr. Falk,
Please leave me alone.
Karen Nichols
The next time I went to the gym,
she said, I came back to my car, and he’d put it back on my windshield in the same place I’d left it on his. If you turn it over, Mr. Kenzie, you’ll see what he wrote.
She pointed at the paper in my hand.
I turned it over. On the reverse side, Cody Falk had written a single word:
No.
I was really starting to dislike this prick.
Then yesterday?
Her eyes filled and she swallowed several times and a thick tremor pulsed in the center of her soft, white throat.
I placed a hand on hers and she curled her fingers into it.
What did he do?
I said.
She sucked a breath into her mouth and I heard it rattle wetly against the back of her throat. He vandalized my car.
Bubba and I both did a double take, looked out at the gleaming green VW Bug parked by the schoolyard gate. It looked as if it had just been driven off the lot, still probably had that new-car smell inside.
That car?
I said.
What?
She followed my gaze. Oh, no, no. That’s David’s car.
A guy?
Bubba said. "A guy drives that car?"
I shook my head at him.
Bubba scowled, then looked down at his combat boots and pulled them up on his knees.
Karen shook her head as if to clear it. I drive a Corolla. I wanted the Camry, but we couldn’t afford it. David’s starting a new business, we both have student loans we’re still paying off, so I got the Corolla. And now it’s ruined. He poured acid all over it. He punctured the radiator. The mechanic said he poured syrup into the engine.
Did you tell the police?
She nodded, her small body trembling. There’s no proof it was him. He told the police he was at a movie that night and people saw him going in and leaving. He…
Her face caved in on itself and reddened. They can’t touch him, and the insurance company won’t cover the damages.
Bubba raised his head, cocked it at me.
Why not?
I said.
Because they never got my last payment. And I…I sent it. I sent it out over three weeks ago. They said they sent a notice, but I never got it. And, and…
She lowered her head and tears fell to her knees.
She had a stuffed animal collection, I was pretty sure. Her totaled Corolla had either a smiley face or a Jesus fish affixed to the bumper. She read John Grisham novels, listened to soft rock, loved going to bridal showers, and had never seen a Spike Lee movie.
She had never expected anything like this to happen in her life.
Karen,
I said softly, what’s the name of your insurance company?
She raised her head, wiped her tears with the back of her hand. State Mutual.
And the post office branch you sent the check through?
Well, I live in Newton Upper Falls,
she said, but I’m not sure. My boyfriend?
She looked down at her spotless white sneakers, as if abashed. He lives in Back Bay and I’m over there a lot.
She said it as if it were a sin, and I found myself wondering where they grew people like her, and if there was a seed, and how I could get my hands on it if I ever had a daughter.
Have you ever been late on a payment before?
She shook her head. Never.
How long have you been insured there?
Since I graduated college. Seven years.
Where’s Cody Falk live?
She patted her eyes with the heels of her hands to make sure the tears were dry. She wore no makeup, so nothing had run. She was as blandly beautiful as any woman in a Noxzema ad.
I don’t know. But he’s at the gym every night at seven.
What gym?
The Mount Auburn Club in Watertown.
She bit down on her lower lip, then tried for that Ivory Snow smile of hers. I feel so ridiculous.
Miss Nichols,
I said, you’re not supposed to deal with people like Cody Falk. Do you understand that? No one is. He’s just a bad person and you didn’t do anything to cause this. He did.
Yeah?
She managed to get a full smile out, but fear and confusion still swam in her eyes.
Yeah. He’s the bad guy. He likes making people afraid.
He does.
She nodded. You see it in his eyes. The more uncomfortable he made me feel in the parking lot one night, the more he seemed to enjoy it.
Bubba chuckled. You wanna talk uncomfortable? Just wait till we visit Cody.
Karen Nichols looked at Bubba and for just a moment she seemed to pity Cody Falk.
In my office, I placed a call to my attorney, Cheswick Hartman.
Karen Nichols had driven off in her boyfriend’s VW. I’d instructed her to drive straight to her insurance company and drop off a replacement check. When she said they wouldn’t honor the claim, I assured her they would by the time she got there. She wondered aloud if she could pay my fee and I told her if she could afford one day, she’d be fine, because that’s all this would take.
One day?
One day,
I said.
But what about Cody?
You’ll never hear from Cody again.
I closed her car door, and she drove off, giving me a little wave as she reached the first traffic light.
Look up ‘cute’ in the dictionary,
I said to Bubba as we sat in my office. See if Karen Nichols’s picture is beside the definition.
Bubba looked at the small stack of books on my windowsill. How do I tell which one’s the dictionary?
Cheswick came on the line and I told him about Karen Nichols’s trouble with her insurance claim.
No missed payments?
Never.
No problem. You said it’s a Corolla?
Uh-huh.
What’s that, a twenty-five-thousand-dollar car?
More like fourteen.
Cheswick chuckled. Cars really go that cheap?
Cheswick owned a Bentley, a Mercedes V10, and two Range Rovers that I knew of. When he wanted to be one with the common folk, he drove a Lexus.
They’ll pay the claim,
he said.
They said they wouldn’t,
I said, just to get a rise out of him.
And go up against me? I hang up the phone without satisfaction, they’ll know they’re already fifty thousand in the hole. They’ll pay,
he repeated.
When I hung up, Bubba said, What’d he say?
He said they’ll pay.
He nodded. So will Cody, dude. So will Cody.
Bubba went back to his warehouse for a while to clear up some business, and I called Devin Amronklin, a homicide cop who’s one of the few cops left in this city who will talk to me anymore.
Homicide.
Say it like you mean it, baby.
"Hey-hey. If it ain’t numero uno persona non grata with the Boston Police Department. Been pulled over recently?"
Nope.
Don’t. You’d be amazed what some guys here want to find in your trunk.
I closed my eyes for a moment. Being at the top of the police department’s shit list was not where I’d planned to be at this point in my life.
You can’t be too popular,
I said. You’re the one who put the cuffs on a fellow cop.
Nobody’s ever liked me,
Devin said, but most of them are scared of me, so that’s just as good. You, on the other hand, are a renowned cream puff.
Renowned, huh?
What’s up?
I need a check on a Cody Falk. Priors, anything to do with stalking.
And I get what for this?
Permanent friendship?
One of my nieces,
he said, wants the entire Beanie Babies collection for her birthday.
And you don’t want to go into a toy store.
And I’m still paying serious child support for a kid who won’t talk to me.
So you want me to purchase said Beanie Babies, as well.
Ten should do.
Ten?
I said. You’ve gotta be—
Falk with an ‘F’?
As in flimflam,
I said and hung up.
Devin called back in an hour and told me to bring the Beanie Babies by his apartment the next night.
Cody Falk, age thirty-three. No convictions.
However…
However,
Devin said, arrested once for violating a restraining order against one Bronwyn Blythe. Charges dropped. Arrested for assault of Sara Little. Charges dropped when Miss Little refused to testify and moved out of state. Named as a suspect in the rape of one Anne Bernstein, brought in for questioning. Charges never filed because Miss Bernstein refused to swear out a complaint, submit to a rape examination, or identify her attacker.
Nice guy,
I said.
Sounds like a peach, yeah.
That’s it?
Except that he has a juvenile record, but it’s been sealed.
Of course.
He bothering somebody again?
Maybe,
I said carefully.
Wear gloves,
Devin said and hung up.
2
Cody Falk drove a pearl-gray Audi Quattro, and at nine-thirty that night, we watched him exit the Mount Auburn Club, his hair freshly combed and still wet, the butt of a tennis racket sticking out of his gym bag. He wore a soft black leather jacket over a cream linen vest, a white shirt buttoned at the throat, and faded jeans. He was very tan. He moved like he expected things to get out of his way.
I really hate this guy,
I said to Bubba. And I don’t even know him.
Hate’s cool,
Bubba said. Don’t cost nothing.
Cody’s Audi beeped twice as he used the remote attached to his key chain to disengage the alarm and pop the trunk.
If you’d just let me,
Bubba said, he would have blown up about now.
Bubba had wanted to strap some C-4 to the engine block and wire the charge to the Audi’s alarm transmitter. C-4. Take out half of Watertown, blow the Mount Auburn Club to somewhere over Rhode Island. Bubba couldn’t see why this wasn’t a good idea.
You don’t kill a guy for trashing a woman’s car.
Yeah?
Bubba said. Where’s that written?
I have to admit he had me there.
Plus,
Bubba said, you know, he gets the chance he’ll rape her.
I nodded.
I hate rape-os,
Bubba said.
Me, too.
It’d be cool if he never did it again.
I turned in my seat. We’re not killing him.
Bubba shrugged.
Cody Falk closed his trunk and stood by it a moment, his strong chin tilted up as he looked at the tennis courts fronting the parking lot. He looked like he was posing for something, a portrait maybe, and with his rich, dark hair and chiseled features, his carefully sculpted torso and soft, expensive clothes, he could have easily passed for a model. He seemed aware that he was being watched, but not by us; he seemed the kind of guy who always thought he was being watched, with either admiration or envy. It was Cody Falk’s world, we were just living in it.
Cody pulled out of the parking lot and took a right, and we followed him through Watertown and around the edge of Cambridge. He took a left on Concord Street and headed into Belmont, one of the tonier of our tony suburbs.
How come you park in a driveway and drive on a parkway?
Bubba yawned into his fist, looked out the window.
I have no idea.
You said that the last time I asked you.
And?
And I just wish someone would give me a good answer. It pisses me off.
We left the main road and followed Cody Falk into a smoke-brown neighborhood of tall oaks and chocolate Tudors, the fallen sun having left a haze of deep bronze in its wake that gave the late winter streets an autumn glow, an air of rarefied ease, inherited wealth, stained-glass private libraries full of dark teak and delicate tapestries.
Glad we took the Porsche,
Bubba said.
You don’t think the Crown Vic would have fit in?
My Porsche is a ’63 Roadster. I bought the shell and little else ten years ago and spent the next five purchasing parts and restoring it. I don’t love it, per se, but I have to admit that when I’m behind the wheel, I do feel like the coolest guy in Boston. Maybe the world. Angie used to say that’s because I still have a lot of growing up to do. Angie was probably right, but then, until very recently, she drove a station wagon.
Cody Falk pulled into a small driveway beside a large stucco colonial and I cut my headlights and pulled in behind him as the garage door rolled up with a whir. Even with his windows closed, I could hear the bass thumping from his car speakers, and we rolled right up the driveway behind him without his hearing a thing. I cut the engine just before we would have followed him into the garage. He got out of the Audi and we left the Porsche as the garage door began to close. He popped his trunk, and Bubba and I stepped under the door and in there with him.
He jumped back when he saw me, and shoved his hands out in front of him as if warding off a horde. Then his eyes began to narrow. I’m not a particularly big guy and Cody looked fit and tall and well muscled. His fear of a stranger in his garage was already giving way to calculation as he sized me up, saw I had no weapon.
Then Bubba shut the trunk that had blocked him from Cody’s view, and Cody gasped. Bubba has that effect on people. He has the face of a deranged two-year-old—as if the features softened and stopped maturing around the same time his brain and conscience did—and it sits atop a body that reminds me of a steel boxcar with limbs.
Who the hell—
Bubba had taken Cody’s tennis racket from his bag, and he twirled it lightly in his hand. How come you park in driveways, but drive on parkways?
he asked Cody.
I looked at Bubba and rolled my eyes.
What? How the fuck do I know?
Bubba shrugged. Then he smashed the tennis racket down onto the Audi’s trunk, drove a gouge in the center that was about nine inches long.
Cody,
I said as the garage door slammed closed behind me, you don’t say a word unless I ask you a direct question. We clear?
He stared at me.
That was a direct question, Cody.
Uh, yeah, we’re clear.
Cody glanced at Bubba, seemed to shrink into himself.
Bubba removed the tennis racket cover and dropped it on the floor.
Please don’t hit the car again,
Cody said.
Bubba held up a comforting hand. He nodded. Then he sliced a pretty fluid backhand through the air and connected with the Audi’s rear window. The glass made a loud popping noise before it dropped all over Cody’s backseat.
Jesus!
What did I say about talking, Cody?
But he just smashed my—
Bubba flung the tennis racket like a tomahawk and it hit Cody Falk in the center of the forehead, knocked him back into the garage wall. He crumpled to the floor and blood streamed from the gash over his right eyebrow and he looked like he was going to cry.
I picked him up by his hair and slammed his back into the driver’s door.
What do you do for a living, Cody?
I…What?
What do you do?
I’m a restaurateur.
A what?
Bubba said.
I looked back over my shoulder at him. He owns restaurants.
Oh.
Which ones?
I asked Cody.
The Boatyard in Nahant. I own the Flagstaff downtown, and part of Tremont Street Grill, the Fours in Brookline. I…I—
Sshh,
I said. Anyone in the house?
What?
He looked around wildly. No. No. I’m single.
I pulled Cody to his feet. Cody, you like to harass women. Maybe even rape them sometimes, knock them around when they don’t play ball?
Cody’s eyes darkened as a thick drop of blood began its descent down the bridge of his nose. No, I don’t. Who—
I backhanded the wound on his forehead and he yelped.
Quiet, Cody. Quiet. If you ever bother a woman again—any woman—we’ll burn down your restaurants and put you in a wheelchair for life. Do you understand?
Something about women brought out the stupid in Cody. Maybe it was the telling him he couldn’t have them in the manner he’d come to enjoy. Whatever the case, he shook his head. He tightened his jaw. A predatory amusement crept into his eyes as if he believed he’d found my Achilles’ heel: a concern for the weaker
sex.
Cody said, Well. Yes, well. I don’t think I can do that.
I stepped aside as Bubba came around the car, pulled a .22 from his trench coat, screwed on the silencer, pointed it at the center of Cody Falk’s face and pulled the trigger.
The hammer dropped on an empty chamber, but Cody didn’t seem to realize that at first. He closed his eyes and screamed, No!
and fell on his ass.
We stood over him as he opened his eyes. He touched his nose with his fingers, surprised to realize it was still there.
What happened?
I asked Bubba.
Dunno. I loaded it.
Try again.
Sure.
Cody’s hands shot out in front of him. Wait!
Bubba pointed the muzzle at Cody’s chest and pulled the trigger again.
Another dry click.
Cody flopped on the floor, his eyes screwed shut again, his face contorted into a puttylike mask of horror. Tears sprouted from under his lids and the sharp smell of urine rose from a burgeoning stain along his left pant leg.
Damn,
Bubba said. He raised the gun to his face, scowled at it, and pointed down again just as Cody opened one eye.
Cody clamped the eye closed as Bubba pulled the trigger a third time, hit another empty chamber.
You buy that thing at a yard sale?
I asked.
Shut up. It’ll work.
Bubba flicked his wrist and the cylinder snapped open. One golden eye of a slug stared up at us, disrupting an otherwise unbroken circle of small black holes. See? There’s one in there.
One,
I said.
One’ll do.
Cody suddenly vaulted up off the floor toward us.
I raised my foot, stepped on his chest, and knocked him back down.
Bubba flicked the cylinder closed and pointed the gun. He dry-fired once and Cody screamed. He dry-fired a second time, and Cody made this weird laughing-crying sound.
He placed his hands over his eyes and said, No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
then did that laughing-crying thing again.
Sixth time’s the charm,
Bubba said.
Cody looked up at the suppressor muzzle and ground the back of his head into the floor. His mouth was wide open, as if he were screaming, but all that came out was a soft, high-pitched Na, na, na.
I squatted down by him, yanked his right ear up to my mouth.
I hate people who victimize women, Cody. Fucking hate ’em. I always find myself thinking, What if that woman was my sister? My mother? You see?
Cody tried to twist his ear from my grip, but I held on tight. His eyes rolled back into his head and his cheeks puffed in and out.
Look at me.
Cody wrenched his eyes back to focus and looked up into my face.
If the insurance doesn’t pay for her car, Cody, we’re coming back with the bill.
The panic in his eyes ebbed as clarity replaced it. I never touched that bitch’s car.
Bubba.
Bubba took aim at Cody’s head.
No! Listen, listen, listen. I…I…Karen Nichols, right?
I held up a hand to Bubba.
Okay, I, whatever you call it, I stalked her a bit. Just a game. Just a game. But not her car. I never—
I brought my fist down on his stomach. The air blew out of his lungs and his mouth repeatedly chomped open and shut trying to get some oxygen.
"Okay, Cody. It’s a game. And this is the last inning. Understand this: I hear a woman—any woman—is being stalked in this city? Gets raped in this city? Has a bad fucking hair day in this city, Cody, and I’m just going to assume it’s you who did it. And we’ll come back."
And paralyze your dumb fucking ass,
Bubba said.
A burst of air exploded from Cody Falk’s lungs as he got them working again.
Say you understand, Cody.
I understand,
Cody managed.
I looked at Bubba. He shrugged. I nodded.
Bubba unscrewed the silencer from the .22. He placed the gun in one pocket of his trench coat, the suppressor in the other. He walked over to the wall and picked up the tennis racket. He walked back and stood over Cody Falk.
I said, You need to know how serious we are, Cody.
I know! I know!
Shrieking now.
You think he knows?
I asked Bubba.
I think he knows,
Bubba said.
A guttural sigh of relief escaped Cody’s lips and he looked up into Bubba’s face with a gratitude that was almost embarrassing to witness.
Bubba smiled and smashed the tennis racket down into Cody Falk’s groin.
Cody sat up like the base of his spine was on fire. The world’s loudest hiccup burst from his mouth, and he wrapped his arms around his stomach and puked in his own lap.
Bubba said, You can never be too sure, though, can ya?
and tossed the tennis racket over the hood of the car.
I watched Cody struggle with the bolts of pain shooting up his body, seizing his intestines, his chest cavity, his lungs. Sweat poured down his face like a summer shower.
Bubba opened the small wooden door that led out of the garage.
Cody eventually turned his head toward mine and the grimace on his face reminded me of a skeleton’s smile.
I watched his eyes to see if the fear would turn to rage, if the vulnerability would be replaced by that casual superiority of the born predator. I waited to see that look Karen Nichols had seen in the parking lot, the same one I’d glimpsed just before Bubba pulled the .22’s trigger that first time.
I waited some more.
The pain began to subside and the grimace relaxed on Cody Falk’s face; the skin loosened up by his hairline, and his breathing returned to a semiregular rhythm. But the fear stayed. It was dug in deep, and I knew it would be several nights before he slept more than an hour or two, a month at least before he could shut the garage door behind him while he was still inside. For a long, long time, he would, at least once a day, look over his shoulder for Bubba and me. Cody Falk, I was almost certain, would spend the rest of his life in a state of fear.
I reached into my coat pocket and pulled out the note Karen Nichols had left on his car. I crumpled it into a ball.
Cody,
I whispered.
His eyes snapped to attention.
Next time, the lights will just go out.
I tilted his chin up with my fingers. You understand? You’ll never hear us or see us.
I shoved the balled-up note into his mouth. His eyes widened and he tried not to gag. I slapped the underside of his chin and his mouth closed.
I stood up, walked to the door, kept my back to him.
And you’ll die, Cody. You’ll die.
3
It would be six months before I gave any serious thought to Karen Nichols again.
A week after we dealt with Cody Falk, I received a check in the mail from her, a smiley face drawn within the o
in her name, yellow ducklings embossed along the borders of the check, a card enclosed that said, Thanks! You’re the absolute best!
Given what would happen, I’d like to say I never heard from her again until that morning six months later when I heard the news on the radio, but the truth is she called once several weeks after I’d received her check.
She reached my answering machine. I came in an hour later to grab a pair of sunglasses, heard the message. The office was closed that week because I was taking off to Bermuda with Vanessa Moore, a defense attorney who had no more interest in a serious relationship than I did. She liked beaches, though, and she liked daiquiris and sloe gin fizzes and nooners followed by late afternoon massages. She looked mouthwatering in a business suit, coronary-inducing in a bikini, and she was the only person I knew at the time who was at least as shallow as I was. So, for a month or two, we were a good match.
I found my sunglasses in a lower desk drawer as Karen Nichols’s voice played through a tinny speaker. It took me a minute to recognize it, not because I’d forgotten how she sounded, but because this didn’t sound like her voice. It sounded hoarse and weary and ragged.
Hey, Mr. Kenzie. This is Karen. You, ahm, helped me out a month ago, maybe six weeks? Yeah, so, ahm, look, give me a call. I, ah, I’d like to run something by you.
There was a pause. Okay, so, yeah, just give me a call.
And she left her number.
Vanessa beeped the horn out on the avenue.
Our plane left in an hour, and traffic would be a bitch, and Vanessa could do this thing with her hips and calf muscles that was probably outlawed in most of Western civilization.
I reached for the replay button and Vanessa beeped again, louder and longer, and my finger jumped and hit the erase button instead. I know what Freud would have made of the mistake, and he’d probably be right. But I had Karen Nichols’s number somewhere, and I’d be back in a week, and I’d remember to call her. Clients had to understand that I had a life, too.
So I went to my life, let Karen Nichols go to hers, and, of course, forgot to call her back.
Months later, when I heard about her on the radio, I was driving back from Maine with Tony Traverna, a bail jumper who was usually considered by those who knew him as both the best safecracker in Boston and the dumbest man in the universe.
Tony T, the jokes went, couldn’t outwit a can of soup. Put Tony T in a room full of horse shit and twenty-four hours later he’d still be looking for the horse. Tony T thought manual labor was the president of Mexico, and had once wondered aloud what night they broadcast Saturday Night Live.
Whenever Tony had jumped bail before, he’d gone to Maine. He’d driven, even though he didn’t have driver’s license. Tony’d never had a license because he’d failed the written part of the exam. Nine times. He could drive, though, and the savant part of him ensured that man had yet to invent a lock he couldn’t crack. So he’d boost a car and drive three hours to his late father’s fishing cabin in Maine. Along the way, he’d pick up a few cases of Heineken and several bottles of Bacardi, because in addition to having the world’s smallest brain, Tony T seemed determined to have the world’s hardest liver, and then he’d hunker down in the cabin and watch cartoons on