Match ends, England 3, Germany 3.
England were denied a dramatic win after a late error by goalkeeper Nick Pope halted a superb comeback and gifted Germany an equaliser in the Uefa Nations League clash at Wembley.
In a game of fluctuating fortunes, Germany looked on course for victory as two bad mistakes from the hapless Harry Maguire put Hansi Flick's side in control.
England manager Gareth Southgate has remained fiercely loyal to the defender despite his struggles at Manchester United but the decision backfired badly.
Maguire lost possession then brought down Jamal Musiala to concede the penalty from which Ilkay Gundogan gave Germany the lead seven minutes after half-time then lost the ball and was left out of position as Chelsea's Kai Havertz curled in a superb second after 67 minutes.
England were facing a third successive defeat but showed great character and resilience to turn the game around and move within sight of what would have been a morale-boosting win in the last game before the World Cup in Qatar.
Luke Shaw pulled one back then a superb equaliser from substitute Mason Mount and a Harry Kane penalty, given after a foul on Jude Bellingham by Nico Schlotterbeck, looked to have capped an unlikely fightback in the space of 12 minutes.
Sadly for Pope, hoping to stake his claim as deputy to first choice Jordan Pickford, he fumbled a routine shot from Serge Gnabry with three minutes left, leaving Havertz to pounce and condemn England to their worst run of results since 1993.
- Pick your England XI for World Cup opener
- Reaction to England 3-3 Germany
- Football Daily podcast: Bellingham stars as England held in six-goal thriller
- Watch The Football News Show on BBC iPlayer
Southgate can take heart
Southgate was stretching reality by claiming England's performance in defeat to Italy on Friday was "a step in the right direction" but there was much more to be satisfied about here despite have to settle for a draw and sixth game without a win.
England showed more attacking intent without the final flourish in the first half and demonstrated real character to battle back from two goals down, with the mood inside Wembley just starting to turn and Germany looking in command.
With nothing to lose and the handbrake off, and with substitutes Mount and Bukayo Saka prominent, England finally gathered the momentum they have lost in recent times and turned the match on its head, finally exerting pressure on Germany and reaping the rewards of those three quick goals.
If England had suffered another loss, it would have been a damaging finale before the World Cup gets under way but the manner in which they picked up the pace to punish a rocky Germany offered more optimism than in any recent performances.
It was another game without a win - but not another game without hope.
Can Southgate stick with Maguire?
The continued selection of Maguire has been a point of debate after his calamitous loss of form and confidence resulted in the Manchester United captain being dropped by manager Erik ten Hag.
Southgate stuck by one of his most trusted players but another poor performance must raise questions about how he can figure in the opening World Cup game against Iran.
Maguire's name received a smattering of boos when it was read out but once the game got under way he had rousing support from a much larger section of England fans.
Unfortunately, Maguire's fragile confidence was exposed when he presented the ball to Musiala then fouled him in a clumsy attempt to regain possession, conceding a penalty in the process.
Maguire then gave the impression of trying too hard, once again presenting the ball to Germany in their own half, with the defender out of the game, and they broke for their second.
If it was a bad night for Maguire it was also a poor one for Pope, who was again far from convincing, uncertain with the ball at his feet then showing poor handling to drop Serge Gnabry's pass into the path of the lurking Havertz.
Player of the match
BellinghamJude Bellingham
England
Avg
- Squad number8Player nameBellinghamAverage rating
7.50
- Squad number18Player nameSakaAverage rating
6.93
- Squad number19Player nameMountAverage rating
6.56
- Squad number7Player nameRiceAverage rating
6.29
- Squad number3Player nameShawAverage rating
5.79
- Squad number9Player nameKaneAverage rating
5.58
- Squad number5Player nameDierAverage rating
5.13
- Squad number4Player nameStonesAverage rating
5.13
- Squad number2Player nameJamesAverage rating
5.02
- Squad number15Player nameWalkerAverage rating
4.97
- Squad number11Player nameFodenAverage rating
4.80
- Squad number10Player nameSterlingAverage rating
4.64
- Squad number14Player nameHendersonAverage rating
4.49
- Squad number1Player namePopeAverage rating
3.53
- Squad number6Player nameMaguireAverage rating
2.58
Germany
Avg
- Squad number7Player nameHavertzAverage rating
7.08
- Squad number14Player nameMusialaAverage rating
6.59
- Squad number21Player nameGündoganAverage rating
6.53
- Squad number22Player nameter StegenAverage rating
6.29
- Squad number9Player nameWernerAverage rating
6.22
- Squad number6Player nameKimmichAverage rating
6.04
- Squad number10Player nameGnabryAverage rating
5.76
- Squad number19Player nameSanéAverage rating
5.74
- Squad number5Player nameKehrerAverage rating
5.72
- Squad number15Player nameSüleAverage rating
5.66
- Squad number18Player nameHofmannAverage rating
5.58
- Squad number3Player nameRaumAverage rating
5.54
- Squad number13Player nameMüllerAverage rating
5.47
- Squad number23Player nameSchlotterbeckAverage rating
5.32
- Squad number17Player nameBella-KotchapAverage rating
5.28
- Squad number20Player nameGosensAverage rating
5.18
Line-ups
England
Formation 3-4-2-1
- 1Pope
- 4StonesSubstituted forWalkerat 37'minutes
- 5Dier
- 6Maguire
- 2James
- 8BellinghamSubstituted forHendersonat 90+1'minutes
- 7Rice
- 3Shaw
- 11FodenSubstituted forSakaat 66'minutes
- 10SterlingSubstituted forMountat 66'minutes
- 9Kane
Substitutes
- 12Trippier
- 13Ramsdale
- 14Henderson
- 15Walker
- 16Coady
- 17Guéhi
- 18Saka
- 19Mount
- 20Toney
- 21Chilwell
- 22Henderson
- 23Abraham
Germany
Formation 4-2-3-1
- 22ter Stegen
- 5KehrerBooked at 82mins
- 15Süle
- 23SchlotterbeckBooked at 82mins
- 3RaumSubstituted forGosensat 68'minutes
- 6Kimmich
- 21Gündogan
- 18HofmannSubstituted forWernerat 45'minutes
- 14MusialaSubstituted forMüllerat 79'minutes
- 19SanéSubstituted forGnabryat 68'minutes
- 7HavertzSubstituted forBella-Kotchapat 90+1'minutes
Substitutes
- 1Baumann
- 4Ginter
- 8Arnold
- 9Werner
- 10Gnabry
- 12Trapp
- 13Müller
- 16Henrichs
- 17Bella-Kotchap
- 20Gosens
- Referee:
- Danny Makkelie
- Attendance:
- 78,949
Match Stats
- Possession
- Home40%
- Away60%
- Shots
- Home13
- Away10
- Shots on Target
- Home8
- Away4
- Corners
- Home6
- Away2
- Fouls
- Home12
- Away8
Live Text
Post update
Full Time
Second Half ends, England 3, Germany 3.
Post update
Nico Schlotterbeck (Germany) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Post update
Foul by Mason Mount (England).
Post update
Thomas Müller (Germany) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Post update
Foul by Harry Maguire (England).
Post update
Serge Gnabry (Germany) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Post update
Foul by Harry Kane (England).
Substitution
Substitution, England. Jordan Henderson replaces Jude Bellingham because of an injury.
Substitution
Substitution, Germany. Armel Bella-Kotchap replaces Kai Havertz.
Post update
Corner, England. Conceded by Marc-André ter Stegen.
Post update
Attempt saved. Bukayo Saka (England) right footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Harry Kane.
Post update
Attempt blocked. Kai Havertz (Germany) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Thomas Müller.
Post update
Kai Havertz (Germany) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Post update
Foul by Harry Maguire (England).
Goal!
Goal! England 3, Germany 3. Kai Havertz (Germany) left footed shot from very close range to the bottom left corner.
Post update
Attempt saved. Serge Gnabry (Germany) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner. Assisted by Thomas Müller.
Post update
Goal! England 3, Germany 2. Harry Kane (England) converts the penalty with a right footed shot to the top left corner.
Booking
Thilo Kehrer (Germany) is shown the yellow card.
Booking
Nico Schlotterbeck (Germany) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Comments
Join the conversation
HOWEVER, tonight showed why he should not be our manager. Persisting with players like Maguire, who continue to make mistakes, will lose us tournaments. It's not good enough. Wise up or get out.
Says it all, we drew with a poor German side, the pundits will think this was a great result.
Poor team, Poor manager
The final result shouldn't hide the fact that his presence in the England squad, never mind the starting lineup, is an absolute travesty.
And yet somehow, he still gets picked by Southgate 🤔
As much as I don't want him in the World Cup, Southgate will continue to select and play his darlings. The only correct choice is Bellingham. He has to start every game, he has earned it.
Can Southgate please explain how this makes any sense?
The Southgate effect 🤡🤦♂️🤣
But it was James so no blame attached!