Has the global exchange industry lost its marbles again?

Back for more

Exchange mergers - Back for more | Finance & economics | The Economist

The Topix falls by 12%, in its worst day since 1987

Why Japanese markets have plummeted

They would be doing even better if the Biden-Harris administration had been more cynical

Swing-state economies are doing just fine

A visit to a crucial swing state reveals the problems she will face

Can Kamala Harris win on the economy?

American and Japanese indices have taken a battering. So have banks and gold

Why fear is sweeping markets everywhere

A new World Bank report takes aim at emerging-market growth plans

India’s economic policy will not make it rich

The Economist invites applications for the 2024-25 Marjorie Deane internship

Wanted: new business, finance and economics interns

We rank popular destinations on two measures

Which cities have the worst overtourism problem?

Finance & economics

Hopes raised, punches pulled

Shifting sands

Grim reaping

The contemporary Keynes

Trust belt

An old problem

Chilling consequences

gv_safe

gb_safe

gb_safe_from_high

gb_safe_from_high_med

pos_goldman_inclusion_2024

pos_israel-hamas_war

gs_busfin

gt_negative

bayer_investment

gs_busfin_economy

gs_personalfin_invest_stocks

gs_personalfin

gs_personalfin_invest

gs_seasevnt_christmas

gs_seasevnt

america_department_commerce

gs_business

cigna_puttingfamilyfirst

gs_economy

fidelity_investment

investment_banking_personal_finance

gs_genres_holiday

gs_genres

neg_omd_exclusion

DAME CLARA FURSE, a former boss of the London Stock Exchange (LSE), used to say that having her Christmas ruined was an occupational hazard. The British bourse, firmly in the second rank of its industry by size, was subject to three festive-season hostile-takeover bids on the trot between 2004 and 2006, all of which failed. Not every deal fizzled: in that same period much of the global exchange industry, like many liberated former monopolies, went on a consolidation bender.

Everyone talked breathlessly about the critical importance of “24/7 global pools of liquidity”, which didn't really mean anything but proved to be an excellent chat-up line. The New York Stock Exchange wooed Euronext, a big Paris-based operator; NASDAQ bought OMX, a Scandinavian firm; Chicago's two big exchanges merged; and in 2007 the LSE itself did a deal, buying Borsa Italiana. The result for shareholders, predictably, was lousy (see chart). Bloomberg's index of global exchanges remains 42% below its 2007 high (global equities are about a fifth below their peak). The sales and profits of the big exchanges in rich countries have stagnated since, too. 

Until late last year the dealmaking had been safely consigned to the annals of shareholder-value destruction. Then, in October, the Singapore Exchange bid for the Australian Securities Exchange (a deal which has yet to close). That was a omen. On February 9th the LSE said it was buying TMX Group, owner of the Toronto stock exchange among other things; and in an echo of the frenzy of yesteryear, later that day Deutsche Börse said it was in talks to buy NYSE-Euronext in a deal that would create the sector's largest firm by market value, worth about $26 billion.

The goodwill from the last round of deals may have been partly written down but the industry's tendency to confuse anodyne descriptions of globalisation with statements of industrial logic remains unimpaired. The Singapore-Australia tie-up was proclaimed under the slogan “Asia Pacific—the heart of global growth”. Xavier Rolet, Dame Clara's successor at the LSE, partly couched the deal with TMX in terms of trade ties between Canada and Europe.

The reality is that the exchange business is unusually unglobal. Securities and derivatives are traded, by and large, in long-standing silos, with their own regulations, laws, working hours and critical mass of big, savvy market participants, who may not all be based in the same country but who share the same rules of engagement. Even if practical, the utility of being able to trade everything, everywhere, all the time is not clear. 

One justification for the recent spate of deals is that exchanges, which tend to have different suites of products, can cross-sell across an expanded customer base—TMX could offer its derivatives products to the LSE's clients, for instance. But there is no good example of this working yet. Another hope is that sales are boosted by the prestige a deal creates. In combination London and Toronto would count for a big chunk of the world's listings of natural-resources firms—perhaps together they would attract even more new listings. It all sounds a bit feeble, though.

What consolidation definitely does involve is bolting together natural product monopolies. Deutsche Börse is big in trading long-term bund derivatives, for example, while NYSE-Euronext is strong in shorter-term interest-rate contracts. Often these long-standing monopolies are under severe pressure from new, low-cost entrants—which is why sales have been falling in bread-and-butter businesses like cash equities. Joining forces does not in itself realise revenue gains or alter this decline. But it may make it possible to combine the technology and back-office platforms being used by different exchanges, cutting costs. Efficiency savings are the one element of the last round of consolidation that did arrive as promised.

Cost savings are being emphasised again now. The Deutsche Börse and NYSE-Euronext combination should yield annual savings of €300m ($412m), the two firms say, equivalent to about a fifth of the combined entity's pre-tax profits, while the LSE-TMX deal should produce savings of about 7%. That is respectable, but not big enough to drive an industry renaissance or to justify another round of bidding wars.

What might is a sense that the regulatory, legal and behavioural boundaries that keep financial activity in silos are breaking down. It has happened before: in most countries shares used to be traded on provincial stock exchanges. If anything, however, the transactions this week show just how far away a global capital market is. Both deals have been presented as mergers of equals with laborious governance arrangements to boot. To work, it seems, international tie-ups must still show that national identities will be preserved. 

Exchange mergers

Weekly insights into a continent that is reshaping our world

Our weekly newsletter will help you make sense of the sweeping changes taking place across Africa

Exclusive insights into a continent that is reshaping our world

Analysing Africa

Get to grips with a region where capital, climate and geopolitics collide

Go deeper with our Middle East newsletter. Every week our correspondents delve into the political, social and economic stories of a region that is rarely out of the news.

Sign up to our Middle East newsletter

Middle East Dispatch

Follow the action in Latin America, from the depths of the Brazilian Amazon to the Mexican-American border

Every week our correspondents share insights on politics, economics and business from an increasingly complex region

Stay informed with our weekly Latin America newsletter

El Boletín

A sharp round-up of the most important US political news

Sign up for updates from our correspondents and data journalists, poll tracker and election-forecast model as the 2024 race unfolds

The US in brief

Inside Europe, from the front lines in Ukraine to the corridors of power in Brussels

Stay informed with our weekly Europe newsletter

Café Europa

Understand a vast and complicated country that will increasingly shape the future

Stay informed with our weekly India newsletter

Essential India

The best of The Economist’s defence coverage, in one place

The War Room

A weekly conversation about culture. Because culture is a serious business

Exploring trends and connections across entertainment, the arts and politics

Broaden your perspective with our weekly culture newsletter

Plot Twist

Analysing the challenges facing Britain and what needs to be done to overcome them

Stay informed with our weekly Britain newsletter

Blighty

Understand what the world makes of China—and what China makes of the world

Stay informed with our weekly China newsletter

Drum Tower

Your essential guide to global business and technology

From supply chains to semiconductors, The Bottom Line newsletter has you covered

Need to track the megatrends shaping business and technology?

The Bottom Line

Catch up quickly on the global stories that matter

Sign up to enjoy a mind-expanding mix of stories, delivered six days a week

Catch up quickly on the stories that matter

The World in Brief

A behind-the-scenes look at how we chose and designed this week’s cover

How we chose this week’s cover image

Cover Story

Exclusive insight from our correspondents in America

Exclusive insight and reading recommendations from our correspondents in America

Checks and Balance

A weekly fix of our mind-expanding science coverage

Curious about the world? Enjoy a weekly fix of our mind-expanding science coverage

Simply Science

Climate-change analysis that you won’t read elsewhere in The Economist

The Climate Issue

Expert analysis of the biggest stories in economics and markets

Money Talks

Taking you behind the scenes of our data journalism

Off the Charts

Long reads and life from 1843 magazine

The Extraordinary Story

The very best of our journalism, handpicked for you each weekday

A daily newsletter with the best of our journalism

Handpicked stories, in your inbox

The Economist today

Highlights from the latest weekly issue, introduced by our editor

Back for more

Has the global exchange industry lost its marbles again?

Finance & economics February 12th 2011

From the February 12th 2011 edition

More from Finance & economics