Leaders | Nuclear deterrence

Beware a world without American power

Donald Trump’s threat to dump allies would risk a nuclear free-for-all

Donald Trump sits next to a NATO flag before a NATO summit in London, UK, December 3rd 2019
Photograph: Getty Images

Nuclear deterrence works—or at least it has so far. To understand how, look at the war in Ukraine. America and Europe arm their ally but dare not deploy combat troops against Russia. In turn, Russia dares not strike at the West. Mutual terror ensures that nuclear powers do not attack each other overtly, just as it stopped the cold war from turning hot, even though plenty of proxy conflicts raged. A sign of success is that only nine countries have nuclear arms—fewer than once feared, and fewer than the number of states able to make them.

As nato this week marks the 75th anniversary of the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty, thank the generosity of“extended deterrence”, by which America has sheltered European and Asian allies under its nuclear umbrella. It has done so in part to contain foes and in part to dissuade friends like Germany, Japan and South Korea from going nuclear themselves.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Leaders section of the print edition under the headline “A world without America’s protection”

China’s risky reboot

From the April 6th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Leaders

Nigel Farage’s claim that NATO provoked Russia is naive and dangerous

It is also a wilful misreading of history

AI will transform the character of warfare

Technology will make war faster and more opaque. It could also prove destabilising


Emmanuel Macron’s project of reform is at risk

A snap election in France reveals the flimsiness of his legacy


More from Leaders

AI will transform the character of warfare

Technology will make war faster and more opaque. It could also prove destabilising


Emmanuel Macron’s project of reform is at risk

A snap election in France reveals the flimsiness of his legacy


The exponential growth of solar power will change the world

An energy-rich future is within reach

India should liberate its cities and create more states

It doesn’t need more government. It needs more governments

Javier Milei’s next move could make his presidency—or break it

Radical experiments with the currency could spell disaster