Got a TV Licence?

You need one to watch live TV on any channel or device, and BBC programmes on iPlayer. It’s the law.

Find out more
I don’t have a TV Licence.

Live Reporting

Edited by Jack Burgess and Marita Moloney

All times stated are UK

  1. Goodbye for now

    Jack Burgess

    Live editor

    We're bringing our live coverage of this story to a close now, but before we go let's quickly recap today's main developments.

    Video content

    Video caption: Dowden blames Chinese groups for two cyber-attacks
    • Deputy Prime Minister Oliver Dowden has told the House of Commons that China is responsible for “malicious cyber campaigns” targeting the Electoral Commission and MPs
    • Dowden says two people and a company linked to the Chinese state have been sanctioned by the UK government
    • The deputy PM has also said the campaigns against the Electoral Commission's systems happened in 2021 and 2022 - but insisted no harm came of the cyber-attacks
    • Dowden has told MPs he would be summoning the Chinese ambassador for an explanation of what happened
    • He also says the attacks by China have not succeeded and the government was taking steps to "address the threat"
    • A Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson has rejected the accusations, while the Chinese Embassy in London has called the claims "fabricated and malicious slanders"
    • Sir Iain Duncan Smith - one of the MPs who says he has been targeted by cyber-attacks - says the sanctions are not enough and likened them to "an elephant giving birth to a mouse"

    You can carry on reading here with our developing story in the US: Millions of Americans caught up in Chinese hacking plot - US

    And also our story on the UK's response: UK sanctions Chinese company over cyber-attacks

    Today's page was edited by Nadia Ragozhina, Marita Moloney and myself.

    It was written by Ali Abbas Ahmadi, Thomas Mackintosh, Tarik Habte and Gem O'Reilly.

  2. Latest sanctions 'not even a significant step in the right direction'

    Ali Abbas Ahmadi

    Live reporter

    The UK government's sanctions on two individuals and one company are "just a tiny, micro, baby step forward" in countering China's influence in the UK, says Mark Sabah, the UK and EU director of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation.

    Speaking to the BBC, Sabah welcomes these sanctions but says they are "not even a significant step in the right direction".

    There should have been dozens of individuals and companies affiliated to the Chinese state sanctioned if the government was serious about taking action, he says.

    Sabah adds that the UK's continued "inaction" over China's behaviour - such as a strongly-worded statement in response to when China "unilaterally tore up" the Sino-British Agreement (that obliges Beijing to uphold Hong Kong's autonomy) - has emboldened China to continue acting as it wants.

    Image caption: An agreement between Britain and China at the time of Hong Kong's handover in 1997 enshrined freedoms for Hong Kong

    If UK's intelligence agencies are saying we are susceptible to Chinese attacks and we do “absolutely nothing”, Sabah says, then of course Beijing is going to continue behaving the same way.

  3. Millions of Americans caught up in Chinese hacking plot - US

    Image caption: US Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco (pictured in 2022)

    More now from the United States, as the justice department and FBI have revealed millions of Americans' online accounts have been caught up in a "sinister" Chinese hacking plot.

    They say US officials were targeted adding the plot allegedly went on for over a decade.

    In an indictment unsealed against seven of the alleged Chinese hackers involved, US prosecutors said the hacking resulted in the confirmed or potential compromise of work accounts, personal emails, online storage and telephone call records.

    The aim of the global hacking operation was to "repress critics of the Chinese regime, compromise government institutions, and steal trade secrets," Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said in a statement.

  4. Seven Chinese nationals charged over hacking by US

    Seven Chinese nationals have been charged with conspiracy to commit computer intrusions and conspiracy to commit wire fraud in New York.

    A statement from the US Attorney's Office in New York states that they were involved with a hacking group that spent roughly 14 years targeting critics of Beijing in the United States and elsewhere.

    Businesses and political officials were also targeted to further China's "economic espionage and foreign intelligence objectives".

    Quote Message: The Justice Department will not tolerate efforts by the Chinese government to intimidate Americans who serve the public, silence the dissidents who are protected by American laws, or steal from American businesses." from US Attorney General Merrick Garland
    US Attorney General Merrick Garland
    Quote Message: This case serves as a reminder of the ends to which the Chinese government is willing to go to target and intimidate its critics, including launching malicious cyber operations aimed at threatening the national security of the United States and our allies." from US Attorney General Merrick Garland
    US Attorney General Merrick Garland
  5. Analysis

    MPs targeted by China don't think UK's doing enough

    Damian Grammaticas

    Political correspondent

    MPs who have been targeted by China clearly don’t think the UK is doing enough.

    Oliver Dowden described a “cyber threat posed by China-affiliated actors”.

    That’s still short of what the MPs want which is to have China as a whole designated a “threat”.

    The UK’s official position remains China is an “epoch-defining challenge”.

    The MPs want a clear message to China and believe the distinction matters.

    Image caption: MPs Tim Loughton, Iain Duncan Smith and Stewart McDonald are all thought have been targeted in cyber-attacks by China

    In the detail too, the UK appears to be treading carefully. It has described the two individuals and one organisation as “Chinese state-affiliated” and imposed economic sanctions.

    Contrast that with the US government. It has today unsealed criminal charges against the same two individuals, along with five others, for conspiracy to commit computer intrusions.

    It has described their actions as part of a “Chinese government” attempt to “target and intimidate its critics”.

    And has detailed what they did, including sending “over 10,000 malicious emails” to “repress critics of the Chinese regime, compromise government institutions, and steal trade secrets”.

  6. UK's accusations are 'fabricated and malicious slanders' - Chinese embassy

    Image caption: Zheng Zeguang had a virtual audience with Queen Elizabeth II on his appointment as ambassador in July 2021

    We have some reaction to bring you from China now.

    On the Chinese Embassy's website there's a question posed to China's ambassador to the UK - Zheng Zeguang.

    It asks: "according to media reports, the UK government will accuse China of launching cyber attacks against the UK. What is your comment?"

    There's a response that appears to be from a spokesperson for the embassy, which says the "so-called cyber attacks" by China against the UK are completely "fabricated and malicious slanders".

    "We strongly oppose such accusations. China has always firmly fought all forms of cyber-attacks according to law," it continues by saying.

    The reply also says China does not "encourage, support or condone cyber-attacks" and opposes the "politicisation of cybersecurity issues" and "baseless denigration of other countries without factual evidence".

  7. Analysis

    UK wants to protect its national interests from Chinese threats

    James Landale

    Diplomatic correspondent

    The British government has a three-pronged policy towards China.

    The tag line is “protect, align, engage”.

    The UK wants to protect its national interests from Chinese threats, it wants to align with allies to agree a collective position towards Beijing, and it wants to engage with China on global issues such as trade and climate change.

    The decision to name and shame Chinese state affiliated actors for cyber-attacks on Britain forms part of that first policy, namely protecting the UK.

    And this is familiar.

    In 2020 the UK decided to phase out Chinese-made Huawei equipment from its 5G network because of potential security fears.

    In recent months, there has been a partial warming in relations.

    The then Foreign Secretary James Cleverly, gave a speech last year emphasising the importance of engaging with China.

    He also visited the country, the first foreign secretary to do so in five years.

    So the calling out of the cyber threat from China will shift the dial the other way and prompt angry denials from Beijing.

    But it will probably not change the fundamental basis of the UK-Sino relationship which blows hot and cold.

    To some this betrays inconsistency.

    To others, inevitability.

  8. UK must 'keep up' defences against Chinese attacks - former diplomat

    A little while ago we heard from former UK diplomat to China Charles Parton, who tells the BBC he shares the prime minister's concerns over China.

    Parton adds that the UK should "keep up [its] levels of protection and defences" even as it co-operates with China.

    Speaking to BBC News, Parton says Beijing is trying to make the UK government more amenable to Chinese interests, and says it's "definitely something we need to defend ourselves against".

  9. Analysis

    Why the Electoral Commission hack was so shocking

    Joe Tidy

    Cyber correspondent

    We've just seen deputy PM Oliver Dowden tells MPs that China is responsible for “malicious cyber campaigns” targeting the Electoral Commission and MPs.

    The sheer size of this hack on the Electoral Commission was eye watering – 40 million people affected. But as ever with cyber-attacks, it’s the quality of data that’s more important than quantity.

    On that metric it was still one of the most significant hacks in history for the British public.

    Databases containing the names and addresses of all registered voters were able to be read and copied by hackers.

    The Electoral Commission played it down at the time arguing that the data was already "largely in the public domain". However, it transpired that more than half of the data – so tens of millions of records weren’t publicly available at all.

    So make no mistake – this could have put a vast amount of private data into the hands of cyber criminals (we still don’t know if they actually did access them).

    However, due to the nature of this hack – for espionage, not money – the accessed data of the general public is probably less important to Chinese cyber spies. It’s likely that having been able to read the toing and froing of sensitive emails between election officials for over a year during six by-elections would have been far more valuable.

  10. Government sanctions not enough, says Iain Duncan Smith

    Former Tory party leader Sir Iain Duncan Smith, who is one of the MPs affected by the Chinese cyber-attack, says he welcomes the sanctioning of the two individuals, but says the deputy PM's announcement is a "like an elephant giving birth to a mouse".

    He says Beijing has "trashed the Sino-British agreement" and has been "committing murder and genocide in Xinjiang" over the past three years. He asks, so why has the UK only sanctioned two people?

    Oliver Dowden replies by saying that "nobody should be in any doubt about the gravity of this matter" and adds they are "not the actions of a friendly state".

    He says the measures announced today are a "first step" and asserts that the government will respond proportionally.

    "Nobody should be in any doubt about the government's determination to face down and deal with these threats to our national security from wherever they come," he concludes.

  11. No specific briefing for Tory 1922 committee - deputy PM

    Dowden is back on his feet insisting the UK will do what is necessary to protect the UK's systems as he answers a couple of questions raised by Labour's Pat McFadden.

    He says Foreign Secretary Lord Cameron's past and present relations and links with China will have been the subject of usual scrutiny.

    Dowden explains that the former prime minister David Cameron is due to speak to the Conservative backbench group, known as the 1922 Committee, later today "on a range of issues" - distancing it from a specific briefing on what has been announced this afternoon.

    Finally, Dowden insists should leaders of the opposition or any other Westminster party wish to have a particular briefing on this matter, then he will make himself available to do so in the normal way.

  12. UK's institutions have not been harmed by attacks - Dowden

    The deputy prime minister has now finished his statement to the Commons.

    Closing his speech, Dowden insists our UK political institutions "have not been harmed by these attacks".

    MPs are now responding to the statement on cyber security and UK democracy.

    Labour's Pat McFadden says his party stands with the government on calling out China and says he wants Dowden to say more about the assessment of the Chinese government's motives for carrying out cyber attacks.

    "With an election coming it is vital people have confidence in their ability to register and vote," McFadden adds.

  13. Cyber threat from China is 'real and serious' - Deputy PM

    Dowden continues by insisting the UK government will condemn "in the strongest terms" threatening behaviours by China and says preventative action will be taken.

    He says the cyber threat from China, "is real and serious" but equalled by the government's resolve to resist it.

  14. UK and allies to stand in solidarity against 'malicious cyber activity' - Dowden

    Dowden goes on to talk about artificial intelligence, and says the Summit for Democracy provided the UK with a platform to build international agreement to counter the deceptive use of AI by foreign states during elections.

    It is important, he says, for allies and other partners across Europe and the Indo-Pacific region to stand in solidarity with the UK's efforts to "call out malicious cyber activity".

  15. UK will continue to hold China accountable - Deputy PM

    Dowden says he will be summoning the Chinese ambassador.

    He says the UK's policy on China is anchored in the country's core national interests but that "swift and robust action" would be taken when China threatens the UK.

    Dowden insists the UK will continue to hold China accountable.

  16. BreakingUK issues sanctions in response to cyber-attacks

    This a consistent pattern of behaviour that "signals hostile behaviour from China", the Deputy PM continues by saying.

    He announces that the UK has sanctioned two individuals and one entity associated with the Chinese state-affiliated APT 31 group for its involvement in "malicious cyber activity targeting officials, government entities and parliamentarians around the world".

    He adds that the UK is acting to warn of the "breadth of targeting" from Chinese state-affiliated actors who want to threaten our democratic institutions.

  17. Targeting of MPs is 'completely unacceptable' - Dowden

    Dowden now turns to the second alleged malicious cyber act that he wants to discuss.

    The Deputy PM says it’s “almost certain” that the China state-affiliated APT 31 group “conducted reconnaissance activity” against UK parliamentarians during a separate campaign in 2021.

    The email campaign by APT 31 was blocked by Parliament's cyber security measures and it was "entirely unsuccessful", he says.

    "However, any targeting of members of this House is completely unacceptable," Dowden adds.

  18. Complex cyber-attack was the work of 'Chinese state actors' - Deputy PM

    The Deputy PM tells Parliament that between 2021 and 2022 the Electoral Commission system in the UK said it had been the victim of a "complex cyber-attack".

    He adds the attack did not succeed but tells the Commons "it was the work of Chinese state actors".

    Dowden insists the security of elections have not been affected and further steps have been taken to increase the resilience of its systems.

  19. Government wants to call out 'pattern of hostile activity' - Dowden

    Dowden continues by saying the government want to be as open as possible with the House of Commons and the British public concerning the attack, in order to call out a "pattern of hostile activity" from China.

    He says Chinese-state actors have been targeting Parliamentarians in the UK and other nations.

    Dowden says China's disregard of human rights and dissenting voices is a cause for concern.

  20. China ‘conducted reconnaissance activity’ against parliamentarians - Dowden

    Dowden lists the two cyber attacks that he believes China is responsible for.

    Firstly, he says China is responsible for an attack on the UK Electoral Commission between 2021 and 2022

    Secondly, Dowden says China ‘conducted reconnaissance activity’ against parliamentarians in 2021.

    The Deputy PM adds that other countries, including the United States, will issue similar statements later today.